In what I have seen of the comments of the English press upon recent
events here, two things are not quite enough kept apart—I mean the
temporary dictatorship of Louis Napoleon to meet and cope with the
expected crisis of ’52, and the continuance of that dictatorship
hereafter,—the new, or as it is called, the _Bas_-Empire—in a word, the
coming Constitution and questionable political machinery with which ‘the
nephew of my uncle’ is now proposing to endow France. Of course, in
reality these two things _are_ separate. It is one thing to hold that a
military rule is required to meet an urgent and temporary difficulty:
another, to advocate the continuance of such a system, when so critical a
necessity no longer exists.
It seems to me, or would seem, if I did not know that I was contradicted
both by much English writing and opinion, and also by many most
competent judges here, that the first point, the temporary dictatorship,
is a tolerably clear case; that it is not to be complicated with the
perplexing inquiry what form of government will permanently suit the
French people;—that the President was, under the actual facts of
the case, quite justified in assuming the responsibility, though of
course I allow that responsibility to be tremendous. My reasons for so
believing I shall in this letter endeavour to explain, except that I
shall not, I fancy, have room to say much on the moral defensibility or
indefensibility of the _coup d’état_; nor do I imagine that you want
from me any ethical speculation—that is manufactured in Printing-house
Square; but I shall give the best account I can of the matter-of-fact
consequences and antecedents of the New Revolution, of which, in some
sense, a resident in France may feel without presumption that he knows
something hardly so well known to those at home.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account