condition of man depended in no degree on his acts, or works, or upon
himself in any form, but on an arbitrary act of selection by God, which
chose some, independently of any antecedent fitness on their part, for
eternal happiness, and consigns all others—irrespective of their guilt or
innocence—to eternal ruin. Nothing, of course, can be more shocking than
such a doctrine when stated in simple language; and if it really were
contained in any document that professes to be a revelation, we should
be plainly justified in passing it by as a document which no evidence
would prove to have been inspired by God. Yet the doctrine certainly
does not want partial analogies in this world. The condition of men here
does seem to be in a considerable measure the result not of what they
do, or of what their characters are, but of the mere circumstances in
which they are placed, over which they have no control, choice, or power.
One man is born in a ditch, another in a palace; one with a gloomy and
painful, another with a cheerful and happy mind; one to honour, another
to dishonour. We invent words—fortune, luck, chance—to express in a
subtle way the notion that some seem the favourites of circumstance,
others the scapegoats. So far as it goes, this is a distinct ‘election’
on the part of God of some to misery, of others to felicity, irrespective
of their personal qualities. Accordingly, it may be argued, why should
we not expect to find the same in the world of revelation, which is
from the hand of the same Creator? But this will scarcely impose on
any one. A certain indignation arises within us—conscience uplifts
her voice, and we reply, ‘It may well be that for a short time God may
afflict His people without their own fault, but that He should do so for
ever—that He should make no end of injustice—that He favours one without
a reason, and condemns another without a fault—this, come what may, we
will not believe—we would sooner cast ourselves at large on the waste of
uncertainty;—pass on with your teaching, and ask God, if so be that He
will pardon you for attributing such things to Him.’ We need not further
enlarge on this.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account