As we have said, the change cannot be helped. A young ladies’ literature
must be a limited and truncated literature. The indiscriminate study of
human life is not desirable for them, either in fiction or in reality.
But the habitual formation of a scheme of thought and a code of morality
upon incomplete materials is a very serious evil. The readers for whose
sake the omissions are made cannot fancy what is left out. Many a girl of
the present day reads novels, and nothing but novels; she forms her mind
by them, as far as she forms it by reading at all; even if she reads a
few dull books, she soon forgets all about them, and remembers the novels
only; she is more influenced by them than by sermons. They form her idea
of the world, they define her taste, and modify her morality; not so much
in explicit thought and direct act, as unconsciously and in her floating
fancy. How is it possible to convince such a girl, especially if she
is clever, that on most points she is all wrong? She has been reading
most excellent descriptions of mere society; she comprehends those
descriptions perfectly, for her own experience elucidates and confirms
them. She has a vivid picture of a _patch_ of life. Even if she admits in
words that there is something beyond, something of which she has no idea,
she will not admit it really and in practice. What she has mastered and
realised will incurably and inevitably overpower the unknown something of
which she knows nothing, can imagine nothing, and can make nothing. ‘I am
not sure,’ said an old lady, ‘but I think it’s the novels that make my
girls so _heady_.’ It is the novels. A very intelligent acquaintance with
limited life makes them think that the world is far simpler than it is,
that men are easy to understand, ‘that mamma is _so_ foolish.’
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account