American essays; Literature -- History and criticism
Indeed, the quality I am speaking of is quite exceptional in the
eighteenth-century writers. It is much more abundant in the writers of
the seventeenth century. It goes much more with the vernacular style,
the homely style, than with the polished academic style.
With the stream of English literature of the nineteenth century has
mingled a current of German thought and mysticism, and this has
greatly heightened its power of suggestiveness both in poetry and in
prose. It is not in Byron or Scott or Campbell or Moore or Macaulay
or Irving, but it is in Wordsworth and Coleridge and Landor and
Carlyle and Ruskin and Blake and Tennyson and Browning and Emerson and
Whitman,--a depth and richness of spiritual and emotional background
that the wits of Pope’s and Johnson’s times knew not of. It seems as if
the subconscious self played a much greater part in the literature of
the nineteenth century than of the eighteenth, probably because this
term has been recently added to our psychology.
As a rule it may be said that the more a writer condenses, the more
suggestive his work will be. There is a sort of mechanical equivalent
between the force expended in compacting a sentence and the force
or stimulus it imparts again to the reader’s mind. A diffuse writer
is rarely or never a suggestive one. Poetry is, or should be, more
suggestive than prose, because it is the result of a more compendious
and sublimating process. The mind of the poet is more tense, he uses
language under greater pressure of emotion than the prose writer, whose
medium of expression gives his mind more playroom. The poet often
succeeds in focusing his meaning or emotion in a single epithet, and he
alone gives us the resounding, unforgettable line. There are pregnant
sentences in all the great prose writers; there are immortal lines only
in the poets.
Whitman said the word he would himself use as most truly descriptive
of his “Leaves of Grass” was the word suggestiveness. “I round and
finish little, if anything; and could not consistently with my scheme.
The reader will always have his or her part to do, just as much as I
have had mine. I seek less to state or display my theme or thought,
and more to bring you, reader, into the atmosphere of the theme or
thought--there to pursue your own flight.” These sentences themselves
are suggestive, because they bring before the mind a variety of
definite actions, as finishing a thing, displaying a thing, doing your
part, pursuing your own flight, and yet the idea conveyed has a certain
subtlety and elusiveness. The suggestiveness of his work as a whole
probably lies in its blending of realism and mysticism, and in the art
of it running parallel to or in some way tallying with the laws and
processes of nature. It stimulates thought and criticism as few modern
works do.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account