Living Fountains or Broken Cisterns: An Educational Problem for ProtestantsSutherland, E. A. (Edward Alexander)
Religion
Living Fountains or Broken Cisterns: An Educational Problem for Protestants
Sutherland, E. A. (Edward Alexander)
Church and education; Education -- History; Religious education
It is not with any spirit of condemnation that these things are stated,
but it can be seen by all that there is a meaning which inevitably
attaches to these changes. The multiplicity of subjects taught has led
to a wonderful book study, and a student’s whole life is spent in an
attempt to put into his own head the thoughts which others have written
for him. The spirit of the universities was caught by the academies, and
by the high schools, and is reflected even in the lower grades. It is the
beginning of the cramming process now so forcibly denounced by a few true
educators. Readers of our magazines are familiar with the ideas expressed
by Mrs. Lew Wallace in “The Murder of the Modern Innocents,” by the
editor of the _Ladies’ Home Journal_, and others. I deem it sufficient
to quote from Mr. Edward Bok, who startled American homes by stating
that “in five cities of our country alone there were, during the last
school term, over sixteen thousand children between the ages of eight and
fourteen taken out of the public schools because their nervous systems
were wrecked, and their minds were incapable of going on any farther in
the infernal cramming system which exists to-day in our schools.... It
was planned by nature that between the years of seven and fifteen the
child should have rest,—not rest which will stop all mental and physical
growth, of course, ... but the child’s pace should be checked so as to
allow him to recover from the strain which his system has just undergone.
“But what really happens to the child at the age of seven? Is he given
this period of rest?—Verily, no! He enters the schoolroom, and becomes a
victim of long hours of confinement—the first mental application, mind
you, that the child has ever known. The nervous wear and tear begins;
the child is fairly launched upon his enjoyment (God save the mark!) of
the great educational system of America.... Special systems of ‘marks,’
which amount to prizes, are started, serving only to stimulate the
preternaturally bright child, who needs relaxation most of all, and to
discourage the child who happens to be below the average of intelligence.
It is cramming, cramming, cramming! A certain amount of ‘ground must be
gone over,’ as it is usually called. Whether the child is physically able
to work the ground, does not enter into the question. And we do not stop
even there! The poor children are compelled to carry home a pile of books
to study, usually after supper, and just before going to bed, and that is
about the most barbarous part of the whole system.”[166]
This is enough to show that the system is recognized as practicing
methods not in accordance with the laws of nature, which are the laws of
God. Such methods are the result of the system at the head of which stand
the colleges and universities which outline the work for all below them.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account