The following passage on what may be called the associations of
antipathy affords a good instance of Locke's power of homely and
apposite illustration:
"Many children imputing the pain they endured at school to their
books they were corrected for, so join those ideas together, that a
book becomes their aversion, and they are never reconciled to the
study and use of them all their lives after; and thus reading becomes
a torment to them, which otherwise possibly they might have made the
great pleasure of their lives. There are rooms convenient enough,
that some men cannot study in, and fashions of vessels, which though
never so clean and commodious, they cannot drink out of, and that by
reason of some accidental ideas which are annexed to them and make
them offensive. And who is there that hath not observed some man to
flag at the appearance or in the company of some certain person not
otherwise superior to him, but because, having once on some occasion
got the ascendant, the idea of authority and distance goes along with
that of the person, and he that has been thus subjected is not able
to separate them."
Had Locke's _Essay_ ended with the Second Book, we should hardly
have detected in it any incompleteness. It might have been regarded
as an analytical work on the nature and origin of our ideas, or, in
other words, on the elements of our knowledge. There are, however,
a third and fourth book--the former treating "Of Words," the latter
"Of Knowledge and Opinion." Locke's notion appears to have been that,
after treating of "Ideas," mainly as regarded in themselves, it was
desirable to consider them as combined in Judgments or Propositions,
and to estimate the various degrees of assent which we give or ought to
give to such judgments, when formed. The Fourth Book thus, to a certain
extent, takes the place, and was probably designed to take the place,
of the Logic of the Schools. "But," to quote Locke's own language in
the Abstract of the _Essay_, "when I came a little nearer to consider
the nature and manner of human knowledge, I found it had so much to do
with propositions, and that words, either by custom or necessity, were
so mixed with it, that it was impossible to discourse of knowledge with
that clearness we should, without saying something first of words and
language."
The last three Chapters of the Third Book are remarkable for their
sound sense, and may still be read with the greatest advantage by
all who wish to be put on their guard against the delusions produced
by misleading or inadequate language--those "Idola Fori" which Bacon
describes as the most troublesome of the phantoms which beset the mind
in its search for truth. Some of the best and freshest of Locke's
thoughts, indeed, are to be found in this book, and especially in the
less technical parts of it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account