Lord Kelvin: An account of his scientific life and workGray, Andrew
Science
Lord Kelvin: An account of his scientific life and work
Gray, Andrew
Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron, 1824-1907
Two objections (apart from the assumptions already indicated) will
readily occur to any one considering this theory, and these Thomson
answered by anticipation. The first is, that no natural action could
possibly bring the surface of a uniformly heated globe instantaneously
to a temperature 7000° lower, and keep it so ever after. In reply to
this Thomson urged "that a large mass of melted rock, exposed freely to
our earth and sky, will, after it once becomes crusted over, present in
a few hours, or a few days, or at most a few weeks, a surface so cool
that it can be walked over with impunity. Hence, after 10,000 years, or
indeed, I may say, after a single year, its condition will be sensibly
the same as if the actual lowering of temperature experienced by the
surface had been produced in an instant, and maintained constant ever
after." The other objection was, that the earth was probably never a
uniformly heated solid 7000° F. above the present surface temperature as
assumed for the purpose of calculation. This Thomson answers by giving
reasons for believing that "the earth, although once all melted, or
melted all round its surface, did, in all probability, really become a
solid at its melting temperature all through, or all through the outer
layer which has been melted; and not until the solidification was thus
complete, or nearly so, did the surface begin to cool."
Thomson was inclined to believe that a temperature of 7000° F. was
probably too high, and results of experiments on the melting of basalt
and other rocks led him to prefer a much reduced temperature. This, as
has already been pointed out, would give a smaller value for the age of
the earth. In a letter on the subject published in Nature (vol. 51,
1895) he states that he "is not led to differ much" from an estimate of
24,000,000 years founded by Mr. Clarence King (_American Journal of
Science_, January 1893) on experiments on the physical properties of
rocks at high temperatures.
It is to be observed that the assumptions made above that the physical
constants of the material are constant throughout the earth, and at all
temperatures, are confessedly far from the truth. Nevertheless Thomson
strongly held that the uncertainty of the data can at most extend the
earth's age to some value between 20,000,000 and 200,000,000 of years,
and that the enormously long periods which were wont to be asked for by
geologists and biologists for the changes of the earth's surface and the
development of its flora and fauna, cannot possibly be conceded.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account