Luck, or Cunning, as the Main Means of Organic ModificationButler, Samuel
Philosophy
Luck, or Cunning, as the Main Means of Organic Modification
Butler, Samuel
Evolution; Natural selection
The vibrations from a pat of butter do, then, actually put butter into a
man’s head. This is one of the commonest of expressions, and would
hardly be so common if it were not felt to have some foundation in fact.
At first the man does not know what feeling or complex of feelings to
employ so as to docket the vibrations, any more than he knows what word
to employ so as to docket the feelings, or with what written characters
to docket his word; but he gets over this, and henceforward the
vibrations of the exterior object (that is to say, the thing) never set
up their characteristic disturbances, or, in other words, never come into
his head, without the associated feeling presenting itself as readily as
word and characters present themselves, on the presence of the feeling.
The more butter a man sees and handles, the more he gets butter on the
brain—till, though he can never get anything like enough to be strictly
called butter, it only requires the slightest molecular disturbance with
characteristics like those of butter to bring up a vivid and highly
sympathetic idea of butter in the man’s mind.
If this view is adopted, our memory of a thing is our retention within
the brain of a small leaven of the actual thing itself, or of what _quâ_
us is the thing that is remembered, and the ease with which habitual
actions come to be performed is due to the power of the vibrations having
been increased and modified by continual accession from without till they
modify the molecular disturbances of the nervous system, and therefore
its material substance, which we have already settled to be only our way
of docketing molecular disturbances. The same vibrations, therefore,
form the substance remembered, introduce an infinitesimal dose of it
within the brain, modify the substance remembering, and, in the course of
time, create and further modify the mechanism of both the sensory and
motor nerves. Thought and thing are one.
I commend these two last speculations to the reader’s charitable
consideration, as feeling that I am here travelling beyond the ground on
which I can safely venture; nevertheless, as it may be some time before I
have another opportunity of coming before the public, I have thought it,
on the whole, better not to omit them, but to give them thus
provisionally. I believe they are both substantially true, but am by no
means sure that I have expressed them either clearly or accurately; I
cannot, however, further delay the issue of my book.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account