On the same occasion he allows himself to be carried away from the
subject of monasticism to the complaints regarding the too frequent
Feasts and Fasts and the formalism pervading the whole life of the
Church, to which we referred on page 227. Returning to the monks, he
declares that he finds the interior man so greatly lacking in them
that (without considering the many exceptions) they were the cause of
the hostile attitude which the world assumed towards them. “Instead
of rejoicing in shame, they are only monks in appearance; but I know
that if they possessed love they would be the happiest of men, happier
than the old hermits, because they are daily exposed to the cross and
contempt. But to-day there is no class of men more presumptuous than
they.”[708]
At the same time, however, he blames the religious who are too zealous
for his liking, saying: “they are desirous of imitating the works
of the Saints and are proud of their Founders and Fathers; but this
is merely trumpery, because they wish to do the same great works
themselves and yet neglect the spirit; they are like the Thomists
and Scotists and the other sects, who defend the writings and words
of their pet authors without cultivating the spirit, yea rather
stifling it ... but they are hypocrites, as Saints they are not holy,
as righteous they are anything but righteous, and, while ostensibly
performing good works, they, in fact, do nothing.”[709]
And what sort of works do the religious perform? “In the same way
that nowadays all workmen are as lazy as though they were asleep all
day, so religious and priests sleep at their prayer from laziness,
both spiritually and corporally; they do everything with the utmost
indolence ... this fault is so widespread that there is hardly one
who is free from it.”[710] “Now,” he exclaims passionately, speaking
of the monks and clergy, “almost all follow their vocation against
their will and without any love for it.” “How many there are who would
gladly let everything go, ceremonies, prayers, rules and all, if the
Pope would only dispense from them, as indeed he could.” “We ought to
perform these things willingly and gladly, not from fear of remorse of
conscience, or of punishment, or from the hope of reward and honour.
But supposing it were left free to each one to fast, pray, obey, go
to church, etc., I believe that in one year everything would be at an
end, all the churches empty and the altars forsaken.”[711] He does
not remember that shortly before he had been complaining that outward
observances were taken too seriously so that they were looked upon as
necessary means of salvation (“_sine his non esse salutem_”), that
“the whole of religion was made to consist in their fulfilment to the
neglect of the actual commandments of God, of faith and love,” and
that the “lower classes observe them under the impression that their
eternal salvation depends upon them.”[712] These complaints, too, he
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account