that some other theologians defended views which were not correct.[779]
But whether such theologians exerted a positive or negative influence
on Luther we do not know. One thing is certain, however, namely, that
he was influenced chiefly by his own desire to free himself from what
he looked upon as an oppressive yoke and that his self-sufficiency
and ignorance speedily led him to fancy it his duty to confront the
theology of previous ages with his epoch-making discovery regarding the
doctrine of fear and penance.
This process is confirmed by a letter of his addressed to Staupitz,
his esteemed Superior, at a time when the commotion caused by his
Indulgence theses was in full swing, which gives us a picture of his
mental state.[780] In it he says:
“The word which I hated most in all the Scriptures was the word
penance. Nevertheless [when performing penance and going to
confession], I played the hypocrite bravely before God, attempting
to wring out of myself an imaginary and artificial love.” He
also grumbles here about the “works of penance and the insipid
satisfactions and the wearisome confession”; such a prominent position
ought not to be assigned to them; the ordinary instructions and
the _modus confitendi_ contained nothing but the most oppressive
tyranny of conscience. He had always felt this, and in his trouble
it had been to him like a ray from heaven when Staupitz once told
him: “True penance is that only which begins with the love of God
and of justice, and what the instructions represent as the last and
crown of all is rather the commencement and the starting-point of
penance, namely, love.” This precious truth he had, on examination,
found to be absolutely confirmed by Holy Scripture (“_s. scripturæ
verba undique mihi colludebant_”)—Luther had a curious knack of
finding in Scripture everything he wanted—even the Greek term for
penance, metanoia, led up to the same conclusion, whereas the Latin
“_pœnitentiam agere_” implied effort and was therefore misleading.
Thus Staupitz’s words had turned the bitter taste of the word penance
into sweetness for him. “God’s commandments always become sweet to us
when we do not merely content ourselves with reading them in books; we
must learn to understand them in the wounds of our Sweetest Saviour.”
The Monk was well aware that such mystical utterances were sure
of finding a welcome echo with the influential Vicar of the whole
Augustinian Congregation, himself a mystic. He sends him with
the same letter his long Latin defence of his Indulgence theses
(_Resolutiones_), which Staupitz was to forward to the Pope.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account