How the ideas of free-will and of God are treated in Luther’s “_De
servo arbitrio_” is made still more plain from the conclusions which he
draws in this work from the denial of free-will, and deals with without
the slightest reserve.
The first consequence is the absolute predestination of the reprobate
to hell.
Luther here throws to the winds the will of God Almighty for the
salvation of all men, and he does so, with regard to those who are
delivered over to eternal death, with a precision which is quite
shocking. They were incapable of being saved because God did not so
will it. Owing to the reprobate, God has “an ‘_æternum odium erga
homines_,’ not merely a hatred of the demerits and works of free-will,
but a hatred which existed even before the world was made.”[760]
Hence He inflicts eternal punishment upon those who do not deserve it
(“_immeritos damnat_”).[761] And if sinners are thereby confirmed in
their sins instead of being converted, this does not matter in the
least, for the Spirit of God will nevertheless, in due season, lay
hold of the elect and change them into children of God (“_electi tamen
manebunt_”).[762]
The severity of his doctrine does not here differ in any way from
Calvin’s cruel views, though, as the fact is less generally known,
Luther’s name has not been so closely associated with predestination
to hell as Calvin’s. Luther’s doctrine on this matter did not come
so much to the front as that of Calvin, because, unlike the latter,
he did not make capital out of it by means of popular and practical
exhortations, and because the early Lutherans, under the influence of
Melanchthon, who became an opponent of the rigid denial of free-will
and of Luther’s views on predestination, soon came to soften their
master’s hard sayings. Yet there can be no doubt that the book “_De
servo arbitrio_” does contain such teaching quite definitely expressed.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account