The singular attitude adopted by Luther is to be explained, as hinted
above, by the fact that, in his work “On the secular power,” he has
allowed himself to be so largely influenced by polemical regard for
the Catholic authorities, whom he describes as those blind, wretched
people, the Emperor and the wise Princes and tyrants generally. He
inveighs against the “clever squires who seek to uproot heresy,” and
against “our Christian Princes, who defend the faith.” The authorities
with whom he is here concerned consist almost exclusively of persons
who, “instead of allowing God’s Word to have free course,” would fain
impose by compulsion the faith of bygone days upon their subjects,
thus creating “liars by constraint.” They “command men to feel with
the Pope,” but they act “without the clear Word of God” and must
therefore necessarily perish in their “perverted understanding.”[874]
In the work in question he nevertheless seeks to establish a general
theory, though, partly owing to its being forcibly shaped to meet the
special needs of the case, partly because it was based on a certain
kind of pseudo-mysticism, the theory remains open to many objections.
The secular power (more particularly where it is Catholic) cannot
exercise any authority in spiritual matters, hence, he says, “these
two governments must be carefully kept asunder, and both be preserved,
the one to render men pious, the other to safeguard outward peace
and prevent evil deeds.”[875] In speaking as he does here and
elsewhere in this work of the “two governments” he is, however, very
far from acknowledging an independent ecclesiastical or spiritual
government such as had existed in Catholicism. What he called
spiritual government was “without law or command,” and merely “the
inward sovereignty of the Word,” “Christ’s spiritual dominion” where
souls are ruled by the Evangel; there the Word of God is furthered
by teaching and the sacraments, by which minds are led and heresy
vanquished; “for Christians must be ruled by faith, not by outward
works.... Those who do not believe are not Christians and do not
belong to Christ’s kingdom, but to the kingdom of the world, and
must therefore be compelled and governed by the sword.” “Christians
do all what is good without compulsion and God’s Word suffices
them.”[876]--Hence it is certain that he does not look upon this
kingdom of the Christian as a real government, seeing that it implies
no jurisdiction. The power to make and enforce laws in this world
belongs only to the secular authorities. They alone form on earth a
real government. “Priests and bishops,” too, have neither “supremacy
nor power.”[877]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account