In connection with the legend of his kindliness, Loesche refers to
a remark made by Melanchthon, according to the “_Dicta_,” about the
year 1553: “Whoever murders a tyrant, as did those who murdered N.
in Lithuania, offers a holocaust to God.”[1189] Such views regarding
the lawfulness of murdering tyrants he seems to have derived from his
study of the classics. He had, moreover, already given expression to
them long before this, referring to Henry VIII. of England, who had
ceased to favour the Reformation as conducted in Germany. In a letter
to his friend Veit Dietrich he wishes, that God would send a brave
assassin to rid the world of the tyrant.[1190]
Melanchthon was in reality far from tolerant, and in his demands for
the punishment of heretics he went to great lengths. It is generally
known how he gave it as his opinion, in 1557, that the execution of
the Spanish doctor, Michael Servetus, which took place at Geneva in
1553 at the instance of Calvin, was a “pious and memorable example for
posterity.”[1191] He wrote to Calvin, on October 14, 1554, concerning
the proceedings against Servetus, who had denied the Trinity as well
as the divinity of Christ, as follows: “I agree entirely with your
sentence; I also declare that your authorities have acted wisely and
justly in putting this blasphemous man to death.”[1192] When the
severity of the step was blamed by some, he expressed his surprise
at the objectors in a letter of August 20, 1555, to Bullinger at
Zürich, and sent him a little treatise defending and recommending
similar sentences.[1193] He there proves that false doctrines should
be treated as notorious blasphemies, and that the secular authorities
were accordingly bound by the Divine law to punish them with the
utmost severity; Divine chastisements were to be apprehended should
the authorities, out of a false sense of pity, show themselves remiss
in extirpating erroneous doctrines. Such was indeed the teaching
at Wittenberg, as evinced, for instance, by a disputation at the
University, where Melanchthon’s friend and colleague, George Major,
branded the contrary opinion as “impudent and abominable.”[1194]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account