Another preacher and theologian with whom Luther was well acquainted
was Andreas Proles († 1503), the founder of the German Augustinian
Congregation to which Luther had once belonged. In the sermons
published by Petrus Sylvius, Proles insists upon the good intention
and interior disposition by which works are sanctified. They are
“smothered,” so he tells his hearers, “if done not out of love for
God but with evil intent, for instance, for the sake of praise, or in
order to deceive, or again, if done in sin or for any bad purpose.”
“Hence ... in the practice of all his works a man must diligently
strive after Divine justice, after a true faith with love of God and
of his neighbour, after innocence and humility of heart, with a good
purpose and intention, since every good work, however insignificant,
even a drink of cold water given to the meanest creature for God’s
sake, is deserving of reward in eternity.... Without charity neither
faith nor good works are profitable unto salvation.”[370]
At about that same time the so-called “holiness-by-works” was also
condemned by the learned Franciscan theologian, Stephen Brulefer.
“Merit,” so he emphasises, “depends not on the number of external
works but on the zeal and charity with which the work is done;
everything depends on the interior act of the will.” Amongst his
authorities he quotes the far-famed theologian of his Order, Duns
Scotus, who had enunciated the principle with the concision of the
scholastic: “_Deus non pensat quantum sed ex quanto_.”[371]
“God wants, not your work, but your heart.” So Marquard of Lindau
writes in his “Buch der X Gepot,” printed in 1483. Before this, under
the heading: “That we must love God above all things,” he declares,
that, whoever does not turn to God with his whole heart cannot merely
by his works gain Him, even though he should surrender “all his
possessions to God and allow himself to be burnt.”[372]
Thus we find in the writings of that period, language by no
means wanting in vigour used in denunciation of the so-called
“holiness-by-works”; hence Luther was certainly not first in the field
to raise a protest.
From their preachers, too, the people frequently heard this same
teaching.
Johann Herolt, a Dominican preacher, very celebrated at the
commencement of the 15th century, points out clearly and definitely in
his sermons on the Sunday Epistles, that every work must be inspired by
and permeated with charity if man’s actions are not to deteriorate into
a mere “holiness-by-works”; a poor man who, with a pure conscience,
performs the meanest good work, is, according to him, of “far greater
worth in God’s sight than the richest Prince who erects churches and
monasteries while in a state of mortal sin”; the outward work was of
small account.[373] Herolt thus becomes a spokesman of “inwardness” in
the matter of the fulfilment of the duties of the Christian life;[374]
many others spoke as he did.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account