The preceding remarks on Luther’s misrepresentations of the Church’s
teaching concerning worldly callings lead us to consider his utterances
on the Church’s depreciation of the female sex and of matrimony.
5. Was Luther the Liberator of Womankind from “Mediæval Degradation”?
Luther maintained that he had raised the dignity of woman from the
depths to which it had fallen in previous ages and had revived due
respect for married life. What the Church had defined on this subject
in the past he regarded as all rubbish. Indeed, “not one of the
Fathers,” he says, “ever wrote anything notable or particularly good
concerning the married state.”[404] But, as in the case of the secular
authority and the preaching office, so God, before the coming of the
Judgment Day, by His special Grace and through His Word, i.e. through
the new Evangel, had restored married life to its rightful dignity,
“as He had at first instituted and ordained it.” Marriage, so Luther
asserts, had been regarded as “a usage and practice rather than as a
thing ordained by God. In the same way the secular authorities did not
know that they were serving God, but were all tied up in ceremonies.
The preaching office, too, was nothing but a sham consisting of cowls,
tonsures, oilings,” etc.[405]
In short, by his teaching on marriage he had ennobled woman, whereas
the Catholics had represented matrimony as an “unchristian” state, only
permitted out of necessity, even though they called it a Sacrament.[406]
_Conspectus of Luther’s Distortion of the Catholic View of Marriage._
Luther based his charges chiefly on the canonical enforcement of
clerical celibacy and on the favour shown by the Church to the vow
of chastity and the monastic life. How this proved his contention it
is not easy to see. Further, he will have it, that the Church taught
that true service of God was to be found only in the monastic state,
and that vows were a sure warrant of salvation--though, as a matter
of fact, neither Church nor theologians had ever said anything of the
sort.[407]
In his remarks on this subject in 1527 he openly accused the Papists
of saying that “whoever is desirous of having to do with God and
spiritual matters must, whether man or woman, remain unmarried,” and
“thus,” so he says, “they have scared the young from matrimony, so
that now they are sunk in fornication.”[408]
At first Luther only ventured on the charge, that matrimony had been
“_de facto_” forbidden, though it had not actually been declared
sinful, by the Pope;[409] by forbidding the monks to marry he had
fulfilled the prophecy in 1 Timothy iv. 1 ff., concerning the
latter times, when many would fall away from the faith and forbid
people to marry. “The Pope forbids marriage under the semblance of
spirituality.”[410] “Squire Pope has forbidden marriage, because one
had to come who would prohibit marriage. The Pope has made man to be
no longer man, and woman to be no longer woman.”[411]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account