Schwenckfeld’s own standard was certainly somewhat one-sided and
his own Apostolic Church, so far as it ever saw the light, fell
considerably short of the ideal. His insight into the ethical
conditions and doctrines was, however, keen enough and his judgment was
at least far calmer and clearer than that of Carlstadt and Luther’s
other more hot-headed antagonists. He was also able to base his
definite and oft-repeated statements on the experience he had gained
during his wide travels and in intercourse with all sorts of men.
Thus he writes: “If by God’s grace I see the great common herd and the
poor folk on both sides, as they really are, then I must fain admit,
that, under the Papacy and in spite of all its errors, there are
more pious, godfearing men than in Lutheranism. I also believe that
they might more easily be improved than some of our Evangelicals who
are now trying to hide themselves and their sinful life behind Holy
Scripture, nay, behind a fictitious faith and Christ’s satisfaction,
and in whom no fear of God is left.”[550]
Many of Schwenckfeld’s more specific complaints are supported by
other witnesses. We may compare what Luther himself and his friends
report of the conditions at Wittenberg[551] with what Schwenckfeld
says a little later: “It is credibly asserted concerning their Church
at Wittenberg, that there such a mad, dissolute life prevails as is
woeful to see; there is no discipline whatever, no fear of God, and
the people are wild, impudent and unmannerly, particularly Philip’s
students, so that even Dr. Major not long since (1556) is himself said
to have complained of it there in a sermon, saying: Our Wittenberg is
so widely talked of that strangers fancy there are only angels here;
when, however, they come they find only devils incarnate. If Philip,
who sends out his disciples as Apostles ‘_in omnem terram_’ does not
found any better Churches than these, he has but little to boast of
before God.”[552]
“What harm and damage to consciences such Lutheran teaching has
brought into Christendom it is easier to bewail with many tears than
to describe.” Though Luther’s “Evangel and office has discovered and
made an end of much false worship and a great apostasy, for which we
give thanks to God the Lord,” yet “it has but little of the power of
grace, of the Holy Spirit, or of blessing, for bringing sinners to
repentance and true conversion.”[553]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account