Luther’s object with the writing in question is to fling at the
Papists his arguments against private Masses under a new and striking
form. He pretends that the Papists would be at a loss to answer
Satan, but would be forced to despair “were he to bring forward
these and other arguments against them at the hour of death.” Hence
he introduces himself and shows how the devil had driven him into
a corner on account of his former celebration of Mass. As for the
arguments they are his usual ones. Here, put in the mouth of the
devil, they are to overwhelm him with despair for his former evil
wont of saying Masses. The only reason he can espy why he should not
despair is that he has now repented and no longer says the Mass.
He himself alludes to the artifice; writing to a friend, he says, that
by the introduction of the devil he intends to attack the Papists
“with a pamphlet of a new kind”; even those friendly to the Evangel
would be astonished at his new way of writing; they were, however, to
be told that this was merely a challenge thrown to the Papists; that
it only represented himself as driven into a corner by the devil on
account of the Masses he had formerly said, in order to induce the
Papists to examine their consciences and see how they could vindicate
themselves with regard to the Mass.[430]—Thus, for once, the devil
might well figure as an upholder of Luther’s doctrine.
In the course of the drama the devil never grows weary of proving,
that, owing to the Masses Luther had said, and the idolatry he had
thus practised, he had been brought to the verge of everlasting
destruction. The devil’s arguments are given at great length and
Luther concedes everything save that he refuses to despair. The
statement that he should, so he urges, is worthy of the devil, who,
in his temptations, constantly confuses the false with the true.[431]
Luther, here, even introduces the devil in a quasi-comic light: “Do
you hear, you great, learned man?” etc. “Yes, my dear chap, that is
not the same,” etc. In a similar tone Luther then turns on the Papists
who say to him: “Are you a great Doctor and yet have no answer ready
for the devil?”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account