Writing of certain kinds of abnormal ideas, viz. those which he
calls “autochthonous,” Carl Wernicke says:[587] “The patient becomes
aware of ideas springing up in his mind that are alien to him and
not his own, i.e. which have not arisen along the normal ideas and
on the ordinary lines of association.” Speaking of those actually
suffering from mental derangement, Wernicke again alludes to this
class: “Objective observers, who are quite conscious of the alien
character of the autochthonous ideas and attach no fundamental
importance to them, are only to be found as the exception among those
who are really mentally unsound. Almost always the ideas are conceived
as ‘ready-made,’ as ‘forced upon the mind,’ as ‘inspired,’ or as
‘derived,’ but, from whom, depends entirely on the individuality of
the patient and on the nature of the autochthonous idea (which is
not uninfluenced by the former). Pious thoughts are inspired by God,
evil thoughts by the devil; more enlightened people have recourse to
material remedies and put their case in the hands of a doctor.”
Of the so-called “exalted ideas” Wernicke says: “These are sharply
defined from autochthonous ideas by the fact that they are in no
way regarded by the patient himself as alien intruders into his
consciousness: on the contrary, he sees in them the stamp of his
innermost self, and fancies that, in vindicating them, he is in
reality asserting his own personality.”
“One has to determine in each individual case whether the idea
is truly morbid and ‘exalted,’ or does not come within normal
bounds.”[588] On the next page he declares: “That almost any incident
may give rise to an ‘exalted idea,’ that the nature of the emotion
may be of the most varied character, and that ideas exist, which,
though in themselves normal, are nevertheless able so to determine the
individual’s action as to impress on it a morbid stamp.”
H. Friedmann[589] says of the same class of ideas: “According to its
origin the ‘exalted’ idea … may find a place in the mental process
without any apparent cause. A strong emotion may, so to speak, fling
itself on a single idea, and, without any actual derangement of the
mind, allow it, and it alone, to assume a morbid supremacy.” A few
pages further we read:[590] “Hence, as a matter of fact, in the case
of the ‘exalted’ idea, we have not an isolated monomaniacal affection
but a general disturbance of the emotions and judgment. The result,
likewise, is not an _idée fixe_ as in the case of mania, but merely a
strong belief.”
CHAPTER XXXVII
LUTHER’S LATER EMBELLISHMENT OF HIS EARLY LIFE
In later life, looking back on his past, Luther was in the habit
of depicting certain of its principal phases in a way which is at
variance with the facts, and which even Protestants in recent times
have characterised, as “a picture in which he becomes a myth unto
himself.”[591]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account