“The reason of my journey to Rome,” he declares, “was to make a
confession from the days of my boyhood and to become pious.”[593]
“But at Rome I came across the most unlearned of men.”[594]—God
“led me, all unwittingly, into the game [his struggle].”[595]
“I behaved with moderation, yet I brought the greatest ruin on
them all.”[596] “I thought I was doing the Pope a service yet I
was condemned.”[597]—“One, and that not the least of my joys and
consolations, is, that I never put myself out of the Papacy. For I
held fast to the Scarlet Woman and served the murderess in all things
most humbly. But she would have none of me, banished me and drove
me from her.”[598] “I only inveighed against abuses and against the
godless collectors of alms and [indulgence] commissioners from whom
even Canon Law itself protects the Pope. The Pope wanted to defend
them contrary to his own laws; this annoyed me. Had he thrown them
over I should in all likelihood have held my tongue, but the hour
had rung for his downfall; hence there was nothing to be done for
him, for when God intends to bring about a man’s fall He blinds and
hardens him.”[599] “I was utterly dead to the world until God thought
the time had come; then Junker Tetzel stung me with his indulgences,
and Dr. Staupitz spurred me on against the Pope.”[600] “Silvester
[Prierias] thereupon entered the lists and sought to overwhelm me with
the thunders of the following syllogism: Whoever raises doubts against
any word or deed of the Roman Church is a heretic; Martin Luther
doubts, etc. With that the ball began.”[601]
Generally speaking, however, Luther prefers to trace the whole of his
quarrel with the Church back to Tetzel and to his righteous censure
of the abuse of indulgences. He seems to have completely forgotten
the deep theological chasm that separated him from the Church even
before his quarrel with Tetzel. His theological attitude at that time,
the starting-point of his whole undertaking, has disappeared from his
purview; he has forgotten his burning desire to win the day for his
own doctrines against free-will, against the value of works, against
justification as taught by Catholic tradition, and for his denial
of God’s Will that all men should be saved. His early antagonism to
the theological schools and to Canon Law as a whole has lapsed into
oblivion.[602]
In the preface to the 1545 edition of his Latin works Luther asserts,
as a fact, that he had been estranged from the Church only through the
indulgence controversy.
He had, so we there read, taken his vocation as a monk quite in
earnest; he “feared and dreaded the Day of Judgment and yet had longed
with all his heart to be saved.… It was not my fault that I became
involved in this warfare, as I call God Himself to witness.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account