In the sermon he preached at Erfurt in 1522 in support of the change
of religion in that town he had declared, that every Christian, thanks
to his kingly priesthood, was an “image of Christ” and a “cleric,” and
“able to judge of all things”; to his decision, based on the Word of
Christ, “the Pope and all his followers were subject”; “he judges all
things and is judged of none.”[804]
Even two years later, in words proclaiming universal freedom of
belief, he had dissuaded the Saxon Princes from taking violent
measures against the fanatics: “Let the spirits fall upon each other
and clash!” What cannot stand must in any case succumb in the fight,
and only those who fight rightly are assured of the crown. “Just let
them preach as they please!”[805]
In 1525 he told Carlstadt and the Sacramentarians that each one was
free to follow his own conscience and to question the Sacrament or
refuse to receive it.[806] This agrees with his statement of 1521: “No
one must be forced into the faith, but the Gospel must be set before
everyone and all be admonished to believe, yet left free to obey or
not. All the Sacraments must be free to everyone.”[807]
Luther registered a formal protest against the ancient right of
proceeding against heretics by means of temporal penalties, particularly
that of death. “To burn heretics is against the will of the Holy Ghost,”
so he declared in 1518 and again in 1520.[808] In 1520 he said: “Heretics
must be overcome by argument, not by fire.”[809]
Most of what he was to say subsequently on the question of public
toleration refers to the bearing of the authorities, especially towards
the Anabaptists and Zwinglians. That he himself, however, and every
follower of his Evangel, were bound to regard all opinions which diverged
from his own as godless heresies and brand them as such, that he had
never doubted from the moment he had discovered his new Evangel. In
accordance with this he proceeds to demand more and more strongly of the
“heretics” within the pale unconditional acceptance of all the articles
of faith.[810]
What were the authorities to do faced by teachings so divergent? In 1523,
in a writing indeed intended mainly for the Catholic rulers and opponents
of his doctrine, Luther is decidedly quite against any interference on
the part of the authorities: “To resist heretics, that is the bishops’
duty to whom this office is committed, not the princes’; for heresy can
never be overborne by a strong hand.… Here God’s Word must fight.”[811]
In April, 1525, in the midst of the Peasant War, in his “Ermanunge,” he
enunciates, not without some thought of his personal ends, this general
principle—“Yes, the authorities must not oppose what each one chooses to
believe and teach, whether it be Gospel or lie; it is enough that they
hinder the preaching of feud and lawlessness.”[812]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account