As to the infallibility of the Church Luther retorted: The invisible
Church cannot err, but “that Church which we usually mean when we use
the word, can and does err; the congregation of true believers cannot
be assembled in one particular spot and is often to be found where
least expected. Moreover, even this Church, i.e. the true believers
and the saints, can sometimes go astray by allowing themselves to be
drawn away from the Word.… Hence we must always regard the Church and
the saints from two points of view, first according to the Spirit,
and, then, according to the flesh, lest their piety and their Word
savours of the flesh.”[1252] The Church teaches according to the
Spirit when her “belief tallies with the Word of God and the belief
of Christ Himself in heaven. To speak in this manner and meaning is
right.”[1253] But “we must not build on her opinion or belief where
she holds or believes anything outside of and beyond the Word of
God.”[1254] It was according to the flesh that all those abominations
of errors were taught which were termed “opinions of the Churches,
though they were nothing of the kind but merely human conceits,
invented outside of scripture and parading under the Church’s
name.”[1255]
With this Luther’s reader is flung back once more into the most
subjective of systems, for who is to decide whether this or that
doctrine “savours of the flesh.” Each one for himself, solely
according to the standard of Holy Scripture or, rather, each one as
Luther dictates. But Luther’s decisions touched only the doctrines
known to him; who is to decide on the questions yet to arise after his
death?
He condemns the errors of the Middle Ages. Yet he is occasionally
ready to praise the Mediæval Church. As we know he acknowledged
that she had preserved Baptism. When the Church says that “Baptism
washes away sin,” this, to Luther, does not savour of the flesh.
“She also holds and believes that in [?] the bread and wine the Body
and Blood of Christ are given.… Summa, in these beliefs the Church
cannot err.”[1256] These, however, merely happened to be Luther’s
own opinions. Infant-Baptism Luther defended against the Anabaptists
without seeking help in the Bible; as for the presence of Christ in
the Sacrament against the Zwinglians he indeed had the words of the
Bible, yet here, too, he was only too glad to reinforce what he said
by the traditions and infallible teaching office of the Church,
though in so doing he was contradicting his own theory.[1257]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account