“Christian dealings with temporal possessions,” he there says, “consist
in three things, in giving for nothing, lending free of interest and
lovingly allowing our belongings to be taken from us [Matt. v. 40, 42;
Luke vi. 30]; for there is no merit in your buying something, inheriting
it, or gaining possession of it in some other honest way, since, if this
were piety, then the heathen and Turks would also be pious.”[232]
This extravagant notion of the Christian’s duties led to his rigid and
untimely vindication of the mediæval prohibition of the charging of
interest, of which we shall have to speak more fully later. It also led
him to assail all commercial enterprise.
Greatly incensed at the action of the trading companies he set about
writing his “Von Kauffshandlung und Wucher” (1524).
Here, speaking of the wholesale traders and merchants, he says: “The
foreign trade that brings wares from Calicut, India and so forth, such
as spices and costly fabrics of silk and cloth of gold, which serve
only for display and are of no use, but merely suck the money out of
our country and people, would not be allowed had we a government and
real rulers.” The Old Testament patriarchs indeed bought and sold, he
says, but “only cattle, wool, grain, butter, milk and such like; these
are God’s gifts which He raises from the earth and distributes among
men”; but the present trade means only the “throwing away of our gold
and silver into foreign countries.”[233]
Traders were, according to him, in a bad case from the moral point
of view: “Let no one come and ask how he may with a good conscience
belong to one of these companies. There is no other counsel than
this: ‘Drop it’; there is no other way. If the companies are to go
on, then that will be the end of law and honesty; if law and honesty
are to remain, then the companies must cease.” The companies, so
he had already said, are through and through “unstable and without
foundation, all rank avarice and injustice, so that they cannot even
be touched with a good conscience.… They hold all the goods in their
hands and do with them as they please.” They aim “at making sure of
their profit in any case, which is contrary to the nature, not only of
commercial wares but of all temporal goods which God wishes to be ever
in danger and uncertainty. They, however, have discovered a means of
securing a sure profit even on uncertain temporal goods.” A man can
thus “in a short time become so rich as to be able to buy up kings and
emperors”; such a thing cannot possibly be “right or godly.”[234]
As a further reason for condemning profit from trade and money
transactions he points out, that such profit does not arise from the
earth or from cattle.[235]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account