Madame Roland: A Biographical StudyTarbell, Ida M. (Ida Minerva)
History
Madame Roland: A Biographical Study
Tarbell, Ida M. (Ida Minerva)
France -- History -- Revolution, 1789-1799; Roland, Madame, 1754-1793
“The present troubles which agitate your department at several points,”
he wrote them, April 18th, “seem to have their source in the diversity
of religious opinions. This diversity of opinion is the fruit of error,
and the error comes from ignorance. If, then, we enlighten men, we
deliver them from prejudices, and if the prejudices were destroyed,
peace would reign on the earth.... It is not by force of arms that one
teaches reason.... In the first place a well-organized state has only
enough troops to prevent invasions, to meet force by force, and to
enable all the citizens to enjoy all the benefits of their own
constitution. Second, internal order should be maintained by
instruction, by public opinion, and finally by the force of the National
Guards.... Elected by the people, you ought to have their confidence.
Your instruction ought to produce the greatest effect, and you ought to
be able through confidence and reason to form and direct public opinion.
These means, used energetically and wisely, are sure. Is there a rare
circumstance when they are too slow? You have all the public force of
your department; you can use it as it is necessary, and you ought to
direct it according to the circumstances. These are your means, sirs,
and you rest responsible before the nation and its representatives,
before the King and your constituency, for all the disorders that you do
not foresee and prevent.”
One can imagine the feelings of a board of county directors harassed by
daily riots, by incessant quarrels, by threats and plots, on receiving
such a letter from the minister, charged with executing the laws
relative to the internal tranquillity of the State. The directory must
have been composed of men singularly devoid of humor, if even in their
grave situation they did not laugh at Roland’s application of
instruction to the Lyons street-fights.
To a department which had asked him for troops to restore order, and
secure the free circulation of grain in its territory, he responded that
if it was necessary to use force they must take the National Guards, and
he added: “But must I counsel this step? So soon as one employs arms to
execute the laws, one not only proves that he has not known how to make
himself loved, but that he will never be able to do so. A constitution
which is enforced by the bayonet only, is not a constitution. Other
means are necessary to attach a free people to the laws that it has
made.... Instruct the administrations that you direct, and if they
deviate from the observation of the rules, use that sweetness which
commands so easily, that persuasion which leads to the repentance of a
fault often involuntary. It is so easy for a superior administration to
make itself agreeable to those that it has under its surveillance that,
in fact, I believe I might say it is always the fault of the former when
harmony is broken.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account