Magna Carta, and Other AddressesGuthrie, William D. (William Dameron)
History
Magna Carta, and Other Addresses
Guthrie, William D. (William Dameron)
Constitutional law -- United States
The right of the states to levy progressive and unequal taxes on
inheritances and testamentary dispositions is frequently sought
to be upheld upon the theory that the power of our legislatures
over successions to the property of decedents is unlimited, that
the right to succeed is a mere statutory privilege, and that our
lawmakers may arbitrarily grant or withhold that privilege at their
will and discretion. It is, however, far from established that
any such arbitrary and unrestrained power is vested in our state
legislatures as that of denying wholly the right of inheritance or
of testamentary disposition, or of discriminating in the regulation
or grant of the privilege. The power to regulate the exercise of any
right does not necessarily imply the power to deny it altogether.
All rights of property as well as of personal liberty are subject to
reasonable regulation, but this does not involve the power absolutely
or arbitrarily to destroy such rights. The right of inheritance by
children was not originally the creation of statute law at all,
although the contrary is often assumed. It was a customary right long
before the Conquest and prior to any statute of which we have record.
It is treated by legal historians as "our common law of inheritance."
In the latest authoritative history of the English law, that by Pollock
and Maitland, the authors say that "in calling to our aid a law of
intestate succession, we are not invoking a modern force," and that
"the time when no such law existed is in strictest sense a prehistoric
time." We find that it was a right already established in every one of
the thirteen original states at the time the national government was
founded; that it has always existed in civilized countries, so far as
we have any knowledge; that it was recognized in the Twelve Tables as
a right among the Romans; that it was a right long before among the
Egyptians, and that it pervades the Mosaic law. A distinguished writer
declares it to be the general direction of Providence itself. And
Chancellor Kent said that "nature and policy have equally concurred to
introduce and maintain this primary rule of inheritance in the laws and
usage of all civilized nations."
The power of testamentary disposition undoubtedly developed
as a limitation upon the right of inheritance and in order to
prevent escheat for want of heirs. But however originating or
evidenced--whether in old customs or in the practice of _post-obit_
gifts--the right has been recognized from time immemorial. As
Blackstone said in his "Commentaries," "in England this power of
bequeathing is coeval with the first rudiments of the law, for we have
no traces or memorials of any time when it did not exist."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account