Magna Carta, and Other AddressesGuthrie, William D. (William Dameron)
History
Magna Carta, and Other Addresses
Guthrie, William D. (William Dameron)
Constitutional law -- United States
An interesting example of the operation of a statute in connection
with established rules of law will be found in the case of Knisley
_vs._ Pratt.[51] The legislature had prescribed certain devices for the
protection of women and children, including a provision that cogs on
machinery should be properly guarded. In enacting this provision, as
the courts were bound to assume by the settled rules of construction,
the legislature was fully aware of the existing law in the state of
New York in regard to the assumption of obvious and ordinary risks of
employment by men and women of full age and capacity. The plaintiff
in the Knisley case was a woman of full age and capacity, and she
was well aware of the danger she was running in approaching too near
machinery in operation. Had the statute been competently drawn, it
would have provided--_assuming, of course, the draftsman and the
legislature so intended_--that the rule of assumption of risk should
not apply to cases within its purview; in other words, it would have
provided that the master should be liable for any injury to a servant
arising from the master's neglect to furnish the protection required
by the statute whether or not the servant knew of such neglect or
contributed in any way to his own injury. No provision of state or
federal constitution prevented the legislature from enacting that the
employer should be absolutely liable for the consequence of his own
deliberate neglect to obey a statutory provision intended to protect
human life and particularly the lives of women and children. There
is not the remotest intimation by the court in the Knisley case that
the legislature could not so alter the law. After the decision in that
case had been announced, a change in the law could have been readily
made within a week, for the legislature was then in session--February,
1896. Yet seventeen years have passed without such an enactment, and in
the meantime the Court of Appeals has been assailed before the whole
country for its lack of sympathy with the poor and helpless and with
social progress as evidenced among other things by this decision!
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account