Mahan on naval warfare : $b Selections from the writing of Rear Admiral Alfred T. MahanMahan, A. T. (Alfred Thayer)
History
Mahan on naval warfare : $b Selections from the writing of Rear Admiral Alfred T. Mahan
Mahan, A. T. (Alfred Thayer)
Naval art and science; Naval strategy; Sea-power
If it be true, as I have expressed my own conviction, that moral motives
are gaining in force the world over, we can have hope of the time when
they shall prevail; but it is evident that they must prevail over all
nations equally, or with some approach to equality, or else discussion
between two disputants will not rest on the same plane. In the
difference between the United States and Spain, I suppose the argument
of the United States, the moral justification to itself of its proposed
action, would be that misgovernment of Cuba, and needless Cuban
suffering, had continued so long as to show that Spain was not capable
of giving good government to her distant dependency. There was no
occasion to question her desire to give it, the honesty either of her
assertions or measures to that end; but it was quite apparent that it
was not in her to give effect to her efforts. Now, presuming Spain to
take that view, it is conceivable (to the imagination) that her rulers
might say, “Yes, it is true, we have failed continuously. The Cubans
have a moral right to good government, and as we have not been able to
give it them, it is right that we should step out.” But, assuming Spain
unequal to such sublime moral conviction and self-abnegation, what was
the United States to do, as a practical matter? What she did was
perfectly practical; she used the last argument of nations as
international law stands; but, suppose she had gone to arbitration, upon
what grounds would the Court proceed? What the solid prearranged basis
of its decision, should that be that Spain must evacuate Cuba? Is there
anything in the present accord of states, styled International Law, that
would give such power? And, more pertinent still, are states prepared
now to concede to an arbitral Court the power to order them out of
territory which in its opinion they misgovern, or which in its opinion
they should not retain after conquest? _e. g._, Schleswig Holstein,
Alsace and Lorraine, the Transvaal, Porto Rico and the Philippine
Islands?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account