Makers of Modern MedicineWalsh, James J. (James Joseph)
History
Makers of Modern Medicine
Walsh, James J. (James Joseph)
Medicine -- Biography
"The chief object of medical science is to relieve suffering and to
save life: you must, therefore, anxiously watch the action of
remedies and, by constantly noting down the effects of treatment,
learn to appreciate its merits and apply it when required. Nor is
this an easy task; some indeed have vainly imagined that the method
of treating or curing disease could be compressed within the limits
of a few short directions made easily deducible from some general
principles and easily applicable in any particular case; but it is
not so. Gentlemen, we have as yet discovered no such general
principles to serve as guides. This discovery presupposes a
knowledge of the laws and relations of the vital powers far beyond
what we now possess: no, we must toil onward by a much more {180}
laborious and circuitous route and must commence by making ourselves
thoroughly masters of a vast number of individual cases, assisted by
the observations and the writings of practical men; we may afterward
proceed to arrange our knowledge, to classify it so as to render it
more available; analogy and induction are here our only or at least
our most valuable guides, and they will seldom fail to instruct us
how to act when properly consulted."
While recognizing all the difficulties of medical practice and the
essential individualization of all its problems, Dr. Graves had little
or no patience with the skeptic who thought that medicine could
accomplish but little for the cure of many ailments. He said once
before the Medico-Chirurgical Society:
"Many, indeed, aiming at acquiring the character of medical
skeptics, think they exhibit proofs of superior discrimination when
they, with apparent candor, make the confession that the more they
see the less confidence they have in the resources of medicine. This
confession should be interpreted not as a reproof of our art, but as
a testimony of the want of skill of the would-be philosophical
asserter of so false a proposition. No, God be praised, our
predecessors have not toiled in vain; the anxious experience of ages
has not been recorded to no purpose; our art is in truth boundless
in resources and, when applied with ability, most successful. There
are, indeed, some acute and many chronic diseases which baffle our
powers of diagnosis, and defy our modes of treatment; such appear to
be, however, not numerous when compared with the great mass of cases
capable of cure or alleviation. The medical skeptic, however acute
his powers of reasoning may be, and however he may labor to render
plain subjects obscure and direct facts ambiguous, can never rob the
good practitioner of the {181} pure, the inward joy he feels when
conscious that he has snatched a patient from the jaws of death."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account