Man's supreme inheritance : $b Conscious guidance and control in relation to human evolution in civilizationAlexander, F. Matthias (Frederick Matthias)
Science
Man's supreme inheritance : $b Conscious guidance and control in relation to human evolution in civilization
So many people, I find, seem to regard the principles of conscious
control as a kind of magic which may be worked by some suitable
incantation. They appear to think that we may obtain conscious control
of, say, the secretive glands, that we may be able to give an order to
secrete more or less bile or gastric juice by a command of the objective
mind. If such a thing were possible, and if I could endow any person
with such power to-morrow, I should know perfectly well that I should,
by so doing, be signing that person’s death warrant; I might equally
well give him a dose of poison. To refer to my metaphor of the sovereign
ruler, you might as well expect a king to order and superintend the
detail of his subjects’ private life as expect the conscious mind
directly to order and superintend every function of the body. If the
king will ordain good and just laws, his policy will prosper; the detail
of organisation must be left to inferior officers. In the care of the
body the organisation is there, aptly and perfectly adjusted to its
functions, and when the ruling power of conscious control has ordained
the sane laws which shall establish peace and prosperity within the
assembly, the organisation already in force will work in harmony to its
fit and proper ends. On the other hand, there is great danger in
underrating the power of conscious control which, if it must not be
prematurely forced and made to intrude on automatic functions, must in
no way be undervalued or delimited.
For instance, though it may not be possible to control directly each
separate part of the abdominal viscera, we can control directly the
muscles of the abdominal wall which encloses the viscera, and in
reducing a protruding abdomen we can control many other muscles, notably
those of the back, which when they are properly employed and
co-ordinated will, by widening and altering the shape of the back, make
place for the protruded stomach, allow it to occupy the natural position
from which it has been ousted, and so give free play once more to the
natural functions of the viscera that have been distorted and pinched by
the forced positions they have had to assume. Here we see that though
conscious control does not affect by a process of direct command, as it
were, the lower automatic functions, there is great danger in assuming
that such functions are beyond the reach of my methods.
This danger was brought before me when I read, in the _British Medical
Journal_ for December, 1909, an article on one side of my teaching
contributed by Dr. S——, an old pupil of mine.
In this article Dr. S—— says:
“Man’s education does not always demand conscious instruction; in the
absence of unfavourable circumstances he can learn by unconscious
imitation of good models.”
Now this is not demonstrably untrue, but at the same time it is, as I
shall show, extraordinarily misleading, and is, in effect, just as
valuable as the prescription of champagne and hothouse grapes for a
pauper patient.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account