Man's supreme inheritance : $b Conscious guidance and control in relation to human evolution in civilization — John Shaqi
Man's supreme inheritance : $b Conscious guidance and control in relation to human evolution in civilizationAlexander, F. Matthias (Frederick Matthias)
Science
Man's supreme inheritance : $b Conscious guidance and control in relation to human evolution in civilization
Nevertheless, if I can judge by my experience of this form of free
expression, the child is encouraged to practise the eccentricity as a
means to obtain the gift of drawing, which as a principle is about the
same as trying to breed race horses with weak lungs because it has been
noted that certain very fast horses have been rather deficient in this
respect. To encourage eccentricity is not to breed genius, and genius
itself is more free and more creative when it is not hampered by
eccentricity. Let us, at least, have some appreciation of rational cause
and effect.
So much for my two “D’s,” but my general criticism of the “free
expression” experiment does not end there. For I must confess that I
have been shocked to witness the work that has been going on in
these schools. I have seen children of various ages amusing
themselves—somewhat inadequately in quite a number of cases—by
drawing, dancing, carpentering, and so on, but in hardly a single
instance have I seen an example of one of these children employing
his physical mechanisms in a correct or _natural_ way. I insist upon
the use of the word _natural_ even though it be applied to such
relatively artificial activities as drawing and carpentering. For
there is a right, that is to say a most effective, way of holding
and using a pencil or a carpenter’s tool. But the children I saw
commonly sat or stood in positions of the worst mechanical
advantage, and the manner in which they held their pencils or their
tools demonstrated very clearly that until their management of such
instruments was corrected, they could never hope to produce anything
but the most clumsy results. Worse still, these children were
forming physical habits which would develop in a large majority of
cases into positive physical ills. A child who tries to guide its
pencil by futile movements of its head, tongue, and shoulders may be
preparing the way to ills so far-reaching that their origin is often
lost sight of.
As an instance of this, I recently had a case of a boy of 3½ years who
suffered from fear reflexes. If a stranger entered a room when the child
was present, he would cry and cling to his mother or nurse. At the
seaside after asking to be allowed to bathe with other children, he was
subsequently afraid to go near the water. And in many other ways he
exhibited unreasoning terrors which, according to the general diagnosis
common in such cases, were presumed to be the cause of his general
backwardness, a symptom particularly marked in his speech, for he was
only able to articulate a few words and those very imperfectly.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account