Mediæval London, Volume 2: EcclesiasticalBesant, Walter
History
Mediæval London, Volume 2: Ecclesiastical
Besant, Walter
London (England) -- History -- To 1500; London (England) -- Social life and customs -- To 1500
The fourth method was the ordeal by fire, in which the accused had
to lift a red-hot bar of iron without burning his hands, or to walk
barefoot over red-hot iron; or to put his hand into a red-hot iron
glove; or to pass through a blazing fire with his clothes untouched.
In the case of the bar of red-hot iron, the trial took place in the
church, and as soon as mass was begun the bar was placed in the coals;
at the last collect it was taken off. A stand of some kind was placed
near the fire, then a space of nine times the length of the prisoner’s
foot was measured off; this made a distance of about seven or eight
feet. This space was divided by lines into three. The prisoner had to
lift up the bar and to carry it by three steps across the space. His
hand was then bound up, and after three days it was examined. If it
showed signs of burning he was hanged.
These kinds of ordeal naturally fell into disuse as soon as people
began to suspect that there was “management” by the priests; their
suspicions began certainly as early as the time of William Rufus, and
perhaps earlier. The Normans, indeed, scoffed at all the old ordeals.
On one occasion, when twenty prisoners had successfully passed the
ordeal by fire, William Rufus laughed at the whole business and ordered
them all to be tried. But the ordeal by battle stood on a different
footing. In this ordeal there could be no deception and no bribing;
the priest had nothing to do with it; the two parties had to fight it
out to the death; it was conducted in grim and solemn earnest; it was
an appeal and a heartfelt prayer to the Lord of Justice. He was called
upon to show the world which was the guilty party. And just as in the
ordeal by water, the consciousness of innocence gave a man assurance,
and thereby enabled him to undertake the fearful task without
confusion or haste, so in the Ordeal by Battle, the consciousness of
innocence sent a man into the field doubly armed.
The mediæval view of the Ordeal by Battle is set forth seriously and
solemnly by Dante (_De Monarchia_, book ii. chap. x.)[19]:—
“Moreover, what is acquired by ordeal is acquired by Right. For
wheresoever human judgment is at fault, either because it is involved
in the darkness of ignorance or because there is not a presiding
judge, then, lest justice should be left deserted, we must have
recourse to Him, who so loved her as Himself to meet her demands
with His own blood in death. Hence the psalm, ‘Just is the Lord, and
deeds of justice hath he loved.’ Now this is what takes place when by
the free assent of either side, not in hatred but in love of justice
the divine judgment is sought through means of the mutual clash of
strength, alike of mind and body. Which clash, since it was first
tried in the single contact of man and man, we call the ordeal.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account