Medical Jurisprudence, Volume 1 (of 3)Paris, John Ayrton
Science
Medical Jurisprudence, Volume 1 (of 3)
Paris, John Ayrton
Medical laws and legislation -- Great Britain
When the more ordinary modes of investigation have failed in leading to
the detection of an imposture, of whose existence we entertain but
little doubt, we may proceed to a system of intimidation, and to severe
discipline; few impostors, however sturdy, can withstand the cravings of
hunger, blistering, the affusions of cold water, and above all a
continual nausea from the administration of divided doses of _Tartarized
Antimony_; and yet exceptions of an extraordinary kind might be adduced;
“I have seen an instance,” says _Dr. Hennen_,[560] “where the patient
admitted of all the preparatory measures of amputation before he thought
proper to relax his knee joint;” the same author also relates the case
of a dragoon who bore very severe riding-school duty for some weeks,
secured to his horse, before he could be brought to acknowledge that his
chronic rheumatism was assumed. _Mahon_[561] records a very
extraordinary instance of a conscript, who feigned blindness, and
baffled every attempt to detect the imposition; he was even placed on
the margin of a river, and desired to go forward, which he did, and fell
into the stream; he was however, without doubt, aware that boats were
provided for his safety, for after having received his discharge, he
freely acknowledged the imposition which he had practised.
Having offered these general remarks, we shall proceed to consider the
particular diseases more usually counterfeited, and the modes best
calculated for their detection; although we must here observe, that
after all that can be said upon the subject, each case will require an
exertion of ingenuity for its detection, for which no previous
instruction can ever provide.
INSANITY has in all ages been feigned for the accomplishment of
particular objects; we read of its having been thus simulated by David,
Ulysses, and Lucius Brutus; the observations which we have already made
upon the subject of imputed insanity, will suggest to the medical
inquirer a plan of examination most likely to lead to a just conclusion.
In general the detection of such an imposture will not be difficult; the
feigned maniac never willingly looks his examiner in the face, and if
his eye can be fixed, the changes in his countenance, on being accused,
will be strongly indicative of his real state of mind; it is moreover,
very difficult to imitate the habits of a lunatic for any length of
time, and to forego sleep; an insane person generally sleeps but little,
and talks much during the night, but the pretender, if he thinks he is
not watched, will sleep, and only act his part when he believes his
conduct to be observed.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account