Medical Jurisprudence, Volume 1 (of 3)Paris, John Ayrton
Science
Medical Jurisprudence, Volume 1 (of 3)
Paris, John Ayrton
Medical laws and legislation -- Great Britain
BEFORE we quit the consideration of _spontaneous combustion_, it becomes
our duty to offer a few observations upon a subject which appears to be
nearly allied to it, and which certainly belongs to medico-judicial
inquiry,—_the combustion of human beings_; the phenomenon, however, has
been erroneously designated as _spontaneous_, for in every recorded
instance, the approach of some burning body, as that of the flame of a
candle, or an ignited pipe, appears to have been necessary for its
occurrence. “It can no longer be doubted,” says _Dr. Gordon Smith_,
“that persons have retired to their chambers in the usual manner, and in
place of the individual, a few cinders, and perhaps part of his bones,
were found.” Upon this occasion we confess ourselves more sceptical; the
phenomenon is contrary to all our preconceived views, and must therefore
require more than ordinary testimony for its support, although we are
ready to admit, that upon any other less miraculous subject, evidence
even less powerful than that produced on the present occasion, would be
deemed amply sufficient. _Plouquet_, in his _Literatura Medica_,
enumerates twenty-eight cases. _Dr. Trotter_, in his Essay on
Drunkenness, adduces a considerable number of instances of persons
addicted to the immoderate use of spirits, having undergone such
combustion. In Paris, an essay written exclusively on this subject was
published by _Pierre Aimée Lair_, entitled “_Essai sur les combustions
humaines, produites par l’abus des liq. spirit: Paris 1808_;” and the
journals of various nations[607] present us with a great variety of
examples, all of which, with some slight shades of difference, appear to
have been attended with the same phenomena: a fact which we freely admit
affords internal evidence of their authenticity. On the other hand it
deserves notice, that amidst all these cases, _only one_[608] is related
where the person survived for a short time, and gave an account of the
manner in which he was _struck_ with the fire; in none of the others has
it ever been known in what way the fire commenced, or proceeded. The
following are the circumstances in which all the recorded cases so
singularly concur.
1. The persons who have suffered this species of combustion have been
long accustomed to drink spirtuous liquors.
2. These persons have been generally females, and advanced in years.
3. The body has not burned _spontaneously_, but accidentally, in as much
as it required for its inflammation the contact or approach of some
burning body, or that of electric matter.
4. The extremities of the body, such as the feet and hands, have in
general escaped.
5. The fire has little injured, and sometimes not at all, those
combustible things that were in contact with the body when it was
burning.[609]
6. The combustion of these bodies has left a residue of greasy and fœtid
ashes and fat, that were unctuous, and extremely offensive and
penetrating.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account