Medical Jurisprudence, Volume 1 (of 3)Paris, John Ayrton
Science
Medical Jurisprudence, Volume 1 (of 3)
Paris, John Ayrton
Medical laws and legislation -- Great Britain
After having determined the age, the most material examination is as to
the relative bodily strength of the parties. It is at all times
difficult to believe that in a mere conflict of strength, any woman of
moderate power of body and mind, could suffer violation, so long at
least as she retained her self possession,[619] All accusation therefore
must be viewed with suspicion, if there be not a great disparity of
strength in favour of the assailant. But this remark must not be
construed to extend to cases, where by long continued violence,
intimidation, or other circumstances, the woman is ultimately overcome;
for her mental suffering may very considerably exhaust her power of
resistance; “and it is no excuse or mitigation of the crime, that the
woman at last yielded to the violence; and consented either after the
fact, or before, if such consent was forced, by fear of death, or
duress,” 1 _Hawk. Pl. c._ 41. _s._ 2. _Co. Lit._ 123. 1 _Hale’s Pl._
629. The mental power of the sufferer is also to be regarded; if it were
considerable, greater power of resistance is to be expected; the
contrary, if the woman were weak and timid; and if she were actually
imbecile, “A poor innocent that could not say him nay;” the crime varies
little or nothing in atrocity from the violation of an infant. We are
not aware that any such case is on record, though the late
investigations into the conduct of some keepers of mad-houses leave
reason to fear that such crimes have been committed.
The external signs of violence ought to be enquired into upon the spot
on which the crime is said to have taken place, and that as soon after
the alleged commission as possible; that the state of surrounding
objects may be determined, as well as the incidental injuries, as
bruises, strains, &c. which either of the parties may have received in
the struggle; the state of their clothes must be examined, and every
circumstance, however minute, carefully noted. The case of _Abraham
Thornton_, Warwick assizes, 1817, and the subsequent proceedings on the
appeal in the King’s Bench, _Easter T._ 1818, 1 _Bar. & Ald._ 405, will
shew how material such examination may prove. Many of the observations
to be made on cases of murder equally apply to those of rape; to them we
must refer.
It is not necessary that the party violated should be proved a
virgin[620] up to the period of the alleged crime; for it may be
committed on the person of a married woman, or of a widow; nay more, the
law extends its protection against violence to those who have been
notoriously unchaste; even a common strumpet is still under the
protection of the law, and may not be forced, (1 _Hawk. Pl._ 108.) and
it is not certain that she had not repented, and determined to reform.
Yet in the case of a person of notoriously bad reputation the strongest
possible evidence would be required to warrant a conviction.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account