right they mean any thing more, I dissent from them. It is admitted by this application that the college have a right to insist on an examination: and upon what ground? as a test of fitness—but though this right is not expressly given to them by the charter, nor is there a word denoting any obligation either to admit or examine, it is incident to their power of judging who is fit to be admitted. That Lord _Mansfield_ thought that they have such a right incidently is clear from what fell from him in Dr. _Askew’s_ case, in which he said, “It is true that the judgment and discretion of determining upon this skill ability learning and sufficiency to exercise and practise this profession is trusted to the college of physicians: and this Court will not take it from them in the due and proper exercise of it.” The same power that authorises them to judge of fitness also authorises them to regulate the mode by which they shall judge. They think, of which they are much better judges than we can be, that every man who is to be a candidate ought either to have taken his degree at one of our universities or in Dublin, or shall be proposed by one fellow, or by the president. The bye-laws requiring this do not appear to me unreasonable or inconsistent with the character any more than requiring a particular mode of education, and in the case so often alluded to Lord _Mansfield_ thought such bye-laws were good; for when he recommended it to the college to revise their bye-laws, he said “Such of them indeed as only required a proper education and a sufficient degree of skill and qualification may be still retained.” In consequence of that opinion the college have reviewed and altered their bye-laws, requiring in some cases an education at either of our universities or at _Dublin_, in others permitting a nomination of persons as fit to be examined by men whom they deem worthy of such a trust, considering such degree and nomination merely as tests of the person taking it or named having skill and learning and being fit to be examined. And in making these bye-laws I think that the college have shewn a due attention to discharge their duty to the public and to attain the ends of their institution. Therefore I concur in the opinion already given that this rule ought to be discharged.