“MADAM,--I am desired by the University Court to inform you
that your letter, dated the 18th ultimo, has been laid before them and
considered.
“In reply, I am to say that in several points of your view of the past
history and present position of the question relative to the medical
education of women in Edinburgh the Court are unable to concur.
“Without going into the discussions which might be raised on these
points, it appears to the Court that it is only necessary for them to
enter upon the subject of your ninth paragraph, in which you say:--
“‘That as the main difficulty before your honourable Court seems to be
that regarding graduation, with which we are not immediately concerned
at this moment, we are quite willing to rest our claims to ultimate
graduation on the facts as they stand up to the present date; and in
case your honourable Court will now make arrangements whereby we can
continue our education, we will undertake not to draw any arguments in
favour of our right to graduation from such future arrangements, so
that they may at least be made without prejudice to the present legal
position of the University.’
“On this I am desired to inform you that you appear to ask no more
than was offered by the Court in their resolution of the 8th ultimo,
in which it was stated that while the Court were restrained by legal
doubts as to the power of the University to grant degrees to women,
from considering ‘the expediency of taking steps to obtain, in favour
of female students, an alteration of an ordinance which might be
held not to apply to women,’ they were, ‘at the same time, desirous
to remove, so far as possible, any present obstacle in the way of a
complete medical education being given to women: provided always that
medical instruction to women be imparted in strictly separate classes.’
“On the assumption, therefore, that while you at present decline the
offer made by the Court with reference to certificates of proficiency,
you now ask merely that arrangements should be made for completing the
medical education of yourself and the other ladies on behalf of whom
you write, I am to state that the Court are quite ready to meet your
views. If, therefore, the names of extra-academical teachers of the
required medical subjects be submitted by yourself, or by the Senatus,
the Court will be prepared to consider the respective fitness of the
persons so named to be authorised to hold medical classes for women
who have in this or former sessions been matriculated students of the
University, and also the conditions and regulations under which such
classes should be held.
“It is, however, to be distinctly understood that such arrangements
are not to be founded on as implying any right in women to obtain
medical degrees, or as conferring any such right upon the students
referred to.
“I have, &c.,
J. CHRISTISON, Secretary.”
(5.) _To the University Court._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account