“SIR,--In the present controversy regarding the extension
to women of facilities for obtaining a complete medical education,
it is reiterated on one side that there is a no demand among women
themselves for doctors of their own sex. In visiting a district
of nine families in a poor quarter of the Old Town, inhabited
principally by Irish, I found four women seriously out of health;
not so seriously, however, but that they might have been cured by
timely medical advice. I urged each of them more than once to go to
the Dispensary, but all persistently refused, each of them saying in
different words that, if ladies were doctors, as they had heard they
were in some places, they would have had medical advice long before.
The feelings of these poor women were so strong on the subject that
I found it was useless to urge them further. It seems only just and
reasonable that qualified female medical attendants should be within
the reach of those who either have a strong preference for it, or who
will not avail themselves of any other.--I am, &c., A DISTRICT
VISITOR.”
_Scotsman_, Dec. 29, 1870.
“As one who, for a short time, was a patient under a late very eminent
doctor of Edinburgh, I say that I believe nothing would again induce
me to do what I then did, in ignorance of what was before me. The
anguish of mind suffered silently by women in such circumstances is
not to be described, and is likely seriously to influence the effect
of the medical treatment. It is surely time for men to cease to speak
of what _women feel_ in this matter. It is impossible for them to
know what women will never tell them--the unwillingness, the delay,
often _too long_, which precedes their stammered request for advice.
What women need is, that some of their own sex should have the power
of qualifying themselves to act as their advisers. Who has a right to
say they shall not, when the voice of their countrywomen calls on them
to do it?--I am, &c., AN ENGLISHWOMAN.”
_Scotsman_, June 6, 1872.
NOTE B, p. 37.
In answer to the sufficiently arrogant enquiry from Dr Henry
Bennet,--“What right have women to claim mental equality with men?”--I
addressed the following letter to the _Lancet_, and as it seems to me
to sum up our position fairly enough, I here reprint it.
EDINBURGH, June 21st, 1870.
“SIR,--I see in your columns of June 18th a letter on ‘Women
as Practitioners of Midwifery,’ and appeal to your sense of fairness
to allow me a fourth part of the space it occupied, for a few words in
reply.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account