While reviewing the above for the press (May 1872), the following lines
came under my notice, and I think them the more suitable to quote as
they are from the pen of a woman who has never herself shown the least
inclination for the study of medicine, and who, therefore, speaks
entirely from the abstract point of view:--
“Nothing will ever make me believe that God meant men to be the
ordinary physicians of women and babies. A few masculine experts
might be tolerated in special institutions, so that cases of peculiar
danger and difficulty might not be left, as they are now, to the
necessarily one-sided treatment of a single sex; but, in general, if
ever a created being was conspicuously and intolerably out of his
natural sphere, it is in my opinion, the male doctor in the apartment
of the lying-in woman; and I think our sex is really guilty, in the
first place, that it ever allowed man to appear there; and, in the
second, that it does not insist upon educating women of character and
intelligence and social position for that post.
“Indeed, common delicacy would seem to demand that all the special
diseases of women should be treated principally by women; but this
aside, and speaking from common sense only, men may be as scientific
as they please,--it is plain that thoroughly to know the women’s
organism, what is good for it and what evil, and how it can best be
cured when it is disordered, one must be one’s self a woman. It only
proves how much unworthy passion and prejudice the great doctors
allow to intrude into their adoration of ‘pure science’ and boasted
love of humanity, that, instead of being eager to enlist the feminine
intuitions and investigations in this great cause, as their best
chance of arriving at truth, they are actually enacting the ignoble
part of churls and misers, if not of quacks. For are they not well
enough aware that often their women patients are so utterly beyond
them that they do not know what to do with them! The diseases of
the age are nervous diseases, and women are growing more nervously
high-strung and uncontrollable every day, yet the doctors stand
helplessly by and cannot stop it. When, however, there shall be a
school of doctresses of high culture and thorough medical education
going in and out among the sex with the proper medical authority, they
will see, and will be able to prevent, much of the moral and physical
neglect and imprudence which, now unchecked in school and home, make
such havoc of the vital forces of the present generation.”
“_Co-operative Housekeeping_,” by Mrs C. F. Pierce.
NOTE E, p. 53.
For the edification of the next generation, to whom all this bigotry
will probably appear almost incredible, I subjoin the passage alluded
to in the text. I am sorry to say it is by no means the worst I might
have quoted from the same paper.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account