“And, after all, what are the arguments on the other side? We are
told oracularly that what is proposed is _contra bonos mores_, and are
warned with equal solemnity of the imminent downfall of any school
that dares to break loose from the bondage of Medical Trades-Unionism
and afford to women exactly the same advantages as to other students.
We do not wish to speak solely, or even chiefly, in the interests of
women; we wish to look at the question broadly and with a view to the
possible moral results to the public at large; and from this point of
view we cannot but feel that the more general association of the sexes
in earnest labour, and especially in scientific and medical study, may
be of the greatest importance to the community. Though the traditions
of the Bob Sawyer period are happily passing away, there yet seems to
linger an idea that medical students as a rule adopt a lower moral
standard and are of a more generally reckless character than those
studying for other professions. If this is so, may not the explanation
be found in the sort of half-expressed idea that seems prevalent in so
many people’s minds that there is in medical study something which, if
not actually improper and indelicate, certainly tends that way, and
had better be ignored as much as possible--something at least which
the average public would probably sum up as ‘rather nasty.’ We believe
that it is on this popular idea--which every true physician would
indignantly disclaim--that the opponents of women’s education trade
when they try to enlist public feeling against mixed classes. They
talk in a vague and very offensive way about certain studies which
form a necessary part of medical education, and not being themselves
capable of seeing the true dignity and profound purity of all science,
especially when pursued with the aim of succouring pain and combating
disease, they manage too often to impress the general public with the
idea that by sanctioning the joint study of medicine by men and women
the said public would commit itself to some shocking impropriety,
all the more awful for being quite indefinite--_omne ignotum pro
magnifico_. It is probable that this sort of vague terror is, in fact,
the best weapon yet forged against women students, but, like many
another terror, it is one that vanishes in the clear daylight. Let it
once be broadly understood that science has no hidden horrors, that
the study of God’s works can never be otherwise than healthful and
beautiful to every student who brings to their contemplation a clear
eye and a clean hand, and this weapon of darkness will be shivered for
ever. We believe, indeed, that nothing could be more desirable for the
average young medical student than to find himself associated in daily
study with women whom he cannot but respect; nothing more calculated
to give him an earnest sense alike of the dignity and of the purity
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account