Medicine and the Church: Being a series of studies on the relationship between the practice of medicine and the church's ministry to the sick
Religion
Medicine and the Church: Being a series of studies on the relationship between the practice of medicine and the church's ministry to the sick
Medicine -- Religious aspects; Pastoral medicine
‘Having recently had to look over a large literature on the subject of
mental healing, ancient and modern, I have tried to put the matter
as succinctly as possible. In all ages and in all climes the prayer
of faith has saved a certain number of the sick. The essentials are,
first, a strong and hopeful belief in a dominant personality, which has
varied naturally in different countries and in different ages: Buddha
in India and in Japan, where there are cults to match every recent
vagary; Æsculapius in ancient Greece and Rome; our Saviour and a host
of Saints in Christian communities; and, lastly, an ordinary doctor
has served the purpose of common necessity very well. Faith is the
most precious asset in our stock-in-trade. Once lost, how long does a
doctor keep his clientele? Secondly, certain accessories--a shrine,
a grotto, a church, a temple, a hospital, a sanatorium [Osler might
have added the admirably devised entourage in such places as ‘Physical
Culture’ Institutes and ‘light cure’ establishments], surroundings
that will impress favourably the imagination of the patient. Thirdly,
suggestion in one of its varied forms--whether the negation of disease
and pain [as among the ‘Eddyites’], the simple trust in Christ of the
Peculiar People, or the sweet reasonableness of the psychotherapeutist.
But there must be the will-to-believe attitude of mind, the mental
receptiveness--in a word, the faith which has made bread-pills
famous in the history of medicine.’ We must, however, recognise the
limitations of ‘mental healing.’ ‘Potent as is the influence of the
mind on the body, and many as are the miracle-like cures which may be
worked, all are in functional disorders, and we know only too well that
nowadays the prayer of faith neither sets a broken thigh nor checks an
epidemic of typhoid fever.’
The following extract is from an article in the _British Medical
Journal_ of March 13, 1909. The article begins by quoting from a paper
by Dr. Allan Hamilton (U.S.A.) to the following effect:
‘In all this agitation, it would almost seem as if the intelligent
physician had never made use of psychotherapy, but that he was a
mechanical giver of drugs and took little or no interest in his
patients. If the new critics of the medical profession, who have been
so active of late, would take the trouble to investigate, they would
often find, among the great and successful men of all times and of
to-day, that the human side is very strongly developed, and that their
patients are studied from every point of view, and treated accordingly.’
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account