Medieval rhetoric and poetic to 1400 : $b Interpreted from representative worksBaldwin, Charles Sears
History
Medieval rhetoric and poetic to 1400 : $b Interpreted from representative works
Baldwin, Charles Sears
Literature, Medieval -- History and criticism; Poetics -- History -- To 1500; Rhetoric, Medieval
Alcuin’s adaptation of the _De inventione_ of Cicero, Walafrid Strabo’s
enumeration of the five ancient parts of rhetoric, do not prove the
use of the whole ancient program. Even the ancient texts would not of
themselves carry on the ancient method. The “_quæstiones civiles_”
often quoted from Cicero’s opening definition could hardly carry their
ancient content either in a society disturbed by the invasions or
in a society reorganizing under feudalism. Moreover the teaching of
_rhetorica_, even when it kept touch with Roman method, was likely to
lean on the _declamatio_ handed down by the schools of Gaul.[34] For all
these reasons the ancient lore naturally most sought and most used was
_elocutio_, the counsels of style. The function of _rhetorica_ is usually
described by some such verb as _ornare_.
Little beyond this is suggested by the summary of Rabanus. Repeating once
more that the field of rhetoric is _quæstiones civiles_, he adds:
Nevertheless [rhetoric] is not outside the scope of training
for the Church. For whatever an orator or preacher of the
divine law sets out capably and fitly in teaching, whatever he
expresses aptly and elegantly in letters, conforms to this art.
_De clericorum institutione_ III. xix; PL 107: 396 C.
The passage is reminiscent of St. Augustine’s _De doctrina
christiana_;[35] and eight later chapters (xxix-xxxvi) follow this
closely, sometimes continuously and word for word. But Rabanus is at once
less specific and narrower as to style. As to composition in the large he
says hardly anything; and he seems to miss the cogency of Augustine’s own
order.
The larger and more vital conception of rhetoric, which was at least
before the eyes of Rabanus, seems more to beckon Loup de Ferrières. Man
of letters in his intellectual eagerness[36] as well as in his style, and
teacher as well, he makes requisitions on the libraries of his friends.
The Quintilian that he needs is not the volume of selections, but all
twelve books;[37] the Cicero, not only the common _De inventione_, but
also the book whose recovery by Poggio in the fifteenth century was one
of the literary events of the Renaissance, the _De oratore_.[38] If these
two cardinal works of the better ancient tradition were not much sought,
at least they were available.
The “three styles” seem already to have been transferred in school from
rhetoric to poetic, and exemplified from Vergil.[39] Mature practise was
already attentive to prose rhythm. Abbo of Fleury, much preoccupied with
this, was also fond of alliteration, and sometimes marked his balances
with rime.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account