Medieval rhetoric and poetic to 1400 : $b Interpreted from representative worksBaldwin, Charles Sears
History
Medieval rhetoric and poetic to 1400 : $b Interpreted from representative works
Baldwin, Charles Sears
Literature, Medieval -- History and criticism; Poetics -- History -- To 1500; Rhetoric, Medieval
(855 B) “For those whose assignments were elementary exercises in
imitating prose or poetry he set poets or orators and prescribed close
imitation after showing the art of connection and of sentence close.[29]
If a boy had brightened his work by sewing on a piece from some one else,
he would show that the theft was detected, but very often would inflict
no punishment. But if the borrowing was misplaced, with modest kindliness
he bade the boy come down to express his author’s likeness; and his own
practise was such that in imitating his predecessors he became a model
for his successors. He also taught among the elements and fixed in mind
the force of composition,[30] the achievement of thought and of phrase,
the character of the style, whether thinness or plausible abundance,
extravagance or just measure.
(855 C) “Stories and poems, he used to say, were to be read carefully,
not on the run; and of each pupil he required as a daily task something
memorized with careful attention. But superfluous reading, he would
add, should be shunned, famous authors are enough. To follow what every
one, however unimportant, has ever said is to regard oneself either
too meanly or too boastfully. It holds back and obstructs minds which
would otherwise make better use of their leisure; and what displaces
something better is so far unavailing that it cannot even be called
good. To explore all papers and ponder all writings, even those not
worth reading, is no more to the purpose than to attend to old wives’
tales. For, as Augustine says in his _De ordine_: ‘Who shall call that
man uncultured who has not heard of the flight of Dædalus, or a liar
for asserting it, or impudent for questioning it? I always feel deep
pity for those of our friends who are accused of ignorance if they have
not answered what was the name of the mother of Euryalus, and who dare
not call the people who ask such questions shallow, impertinent, and
curious.’ So says Augustine both neatly and truly. Therefore it was
rightly reckoned by the ancients among the virtues of a _grammaticus_
that there should be some things which he did not know.
(856 A) “Since in all the preliminary exercises nothing is more useful
than to accustom oneself to what ought to be done expertly, Bernard’s
students would daily write prose and verse and practise themselves
by exchange of criticism. Nothing is more useful than this exercise
for expression, nothing more promotive of learning; and its greatest
contribution is to the conduct of life, provided this insistence be
controlled by charity, and progress in literature contribute to humility.”
The last chapter (xxv) quotes at length the _laus grammaticæ_ of
Quintilian I. iv. 5-6.[31]
BOOK II. _DEMONSTRATIVA_ AND _DIALECTICA_
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account