Medieval rhetoric and poetic to 1400 : $b Interpreted from representative worksBaldwin, Charles Sears
History
Medieval rhetoric and poetic to 1400 : $b Interpreted from representative works
Baldwin, Charles Sears
Literature, Medieval -- History and criticism; Poetics -- History -- To 1500; Rhetoric, Medieval
Although the whole epistle, except in the elegant last part, is
written in the plain style, nevertheless the apostle inserts
a certain passage of such moving force that it must be called
great even though it has no such embellishments as those just
cited.... Is there here either antithesis, or subordination for
climax, or rhythm in phrase, clause, or period? None the less
for that there is no cooling of the great emotion with which we
feel the style to glow. xx.
After quoting without further comment examples from Cyprian and Ambrose,
Augustine shows (xxii, xxiii) the need of variety. More even than other
forms of oratory, preaching seems to suffer from a stylistic level. No
one of the three styles, least of all the third, can effectively be
prolonged; the change from style to style gives relief; and subordination
of what might be heightened may enhance the emotion of what must be.
What must be heightened is what is to rouse the audience to action. So
the test of achievement in the third style is not applause, but tears
and change of life (xxiv). So also the end of all eloquence, in whatever
style, is persuasion (xxv).
In the restrained style the orator persuades of truth. In the
great style he persuades to action. In the elegant style is
he to persuade himself that he is speaking beautifully? With
such an end what have we to do? Let them seek it who glory
in language, who display themselves in panegyrics and such
exercises, in which the hearer is neither to be instructed nor
to be moved to any action, but merely to be pleased. But let us
judge this end by another end. xxv.
Thus Augustine is more explicit than Cicero in showing that the three
typical styles are but three ways (xxvi) of achieving a single end, even
as the three corresponding tasks, though one of them absorbs attention
at a time, are but three aspects of the single task. Nor can persuasion
dispense with a means beyond art, the appeal of the speaker’s life[25]
(xxvii). Though the Church speaks not merely through a man, but through
his office, persuasion needs for full effect his whole influence. Because
his life is without shame, the preacher speaks not shamelessly (xxviii),
not only with restraint and charm, but with power, to win obedience to
the truth.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account