Attached to the sentence was the following recommendation of the court:-- "The court having performed a painful but imperative duty, in finding the prisoner guilty, beg respectfully, though earnestly, to recommend him to the clemency of his excellency the commander-in-chief. In presuming to express a wish that mercy may be extended to the present case, the court are impressed with a hope that the gallantry so frequently displayed by the prisoner, the numerous wounds he has received, and the high and apparently merited character which he has hitherto borne, will appear to his excellency sufficient grounds for the court's thus warmly interesting themselves in the prisoner's fate, and urging with anxious solicitude the present recommendation. "Before closing their proceedings, the court deem it a justice due to Lieutenant-Colonel Browne, to express their opinion that his conduct, as far as it has come before them, has been honourable to himself and indulgent towards the prisoner." _Remarks by the Commander-in-Chief._ "Lieutenant Shipp has thus, by his persevering resistance to the advice of his late most respected commanding-officer, of the general of his division, and of the commander-in-chief, brought upon himself the heavy penalty of the forfeiture of his commission. Although these are circumstances calculated greatly to aggravate the offences of this officer, still the commander-in-chief is willing to hope that, in yielding, as far as he feels it is consistent with his duty, to the earnest intercession of the court, he runs no risk of shaking the foundations of discipline and subordination. The sentence of the court is accordingly remitted; but as, under all the circumstances of the case, the commander-in-chief deems it quite impossible that Lieutenant Shipp should continue to do duty with the 87th regiment, he grants him leave of absence from it, and shall recommend that he be removed to the half-pay list. "The foregoing orders to be entered in the General Order-Book, and read at the head of every regiment in his Majesty's service in India. "By order of his Excellency the Commander-in-Chief, (Signed) "THOMAS M'MAHON, (A true copy.) "_Colonel, Adjutant-General._" "_J Bowes, Lieutenant and Adjutant, 87th Regiment._" On the tenth day of the proceedings, Colonel Browne, being examined on oath, is questioned by the court:-- _Question._--"How long have you known the prisoner, and what was your opinion of his character previous to the misunderstanding between you and him?"