[186] Of the two accounts of Lord Lovat's imprisonment, namely, Mr. Arbuthnot's and Lord Lovat's, the latter bears, strange to say, the greatest air of truth. Mr. Arbuthnot's, independent of his erring in the place of imprisonment, appears to me a pure romance. [187] Manifesto, p. 301. [188] Carstares. State Papers, p. 718. [189] Manifesto, p. 328. [190] Anderson, p. 137. [191] Id. p. 138. [192] Free Examination of the Memoir of Lord Lovat, quoted in Arbuthnot, p. 201. [193] Anderson, p. 136. [194] From the Macpherson Papers, vol. ii. p. 622. [195] Culloden Papers, p. 32. [196] Manifesto, p. 466. [197] Ibid. p. 468. [198] Smollet, p. xi. Patten's History of the Rebellion, p. 2. [199] Arbuthnot, p. 210. [200] Edinburgh Review, No. li. art. _Culloden Papers_, 1826. This article is attributed to the Honourable Lord Cockburn. [201] See Introduction to the Culloden Papers. [202] Arbuthnot, p. 211. [203] Shaw's Hist. of Moray, p. 252. [204] Ibid. [205] Anderson, p. 141. [206] Arbuthnot, p. 218. [207] Shaw, p. 186. [208] Such was the style in which Lovat, to be complimentary, usually addressed Duncan Forbes, on account of the military capacity in which the future Lord President had acted during the Rebellion. [209] Culloden Papers, p. 55. [210] Culloden Papers, p. 56. [211] Sergeant Macleod served in 1703, when only thirteen years of age, in the Scots Royals, afterwards under Marlborough, then at the battle of Sherriff Muir in 1715. After a variety of campaigns he was wounded in the battle of Quebec, in 1759, and came home in the same ship that brought General Wolf's body to England. Macleod died in Chelsea Hospital at the age of one hundred and three. His Memoirs are interesting. [212] Memoirs of the Life of Sergeant Donald Macleod, p. 45. London, 1791. [213] Anderson. From King's Monumenta Antiqua. [214] Culloden Papers. [215] Mrs. Grant's MS. [216] Anderson, p. 159. From family archives. [217] Chambers's Traditions of Edinburgh. [218] Chambers's Traditions of Edinburgh, p. 21. [219] Culloden Papers, "Quarterly Review," vol. xiv. This article is written by Sir Walter Scott, and the anecdote is given on his personal knowledge. [220] Arbuthnot, p. 249. [221] Lady Grange's Memoirs. [222] Arbuthnot, p. 241. [223] Arbuthnot. [224] Quarterly Review, vol. xiv. Culloden Papers. [225] Culloden Papers, p. 72. [226] Burt's Letters from the North, vol. xxi. [227] Culloden Papers, p. 106. [228] Arbuthnot, p. 250. [229] Culloden Papers, p. 106. [230] Henderson's History of the Rebellion, p. 8. [231] Henderson, p. 10. [232] James Maxwell, of Kirkconnell; his narrative, of which I have a copy, has been printed for the Maitland Club, in Edinburgh; it is remarkably clear, and ably and dispassionately written, and was composed immediately after the events of the year 1745, of which Mr. Maxwell was an eye-witness. [233] Maxwell of Kirkconnell's Narrative of the Prince's Expedition, p. 10.