Memorials and Other Papers — Volume 1De Quincey, Thomas
General
Memorials and Other Papers — Volume 1
De Quincey, Thomas
English essays
"Such gifts as we greet modern friends withal;"
where all commentators have _felt_ that modern must form the position,
mean, slight, and inconsiderable, though perplexed to say how it came
by such a meaning. A _modern_ friend is, in the Shakspearian sense, with
relation to a real and serviceable friend, that which the fashion of
a thing is, by comparison with its substance. But a still better
illustration may be taken from a common line, quoted every day, and
ludicrously misinterpreted. In the famous picture of life--"All the
world's a stage"--the justice of the piece is described as
"Full of wise saws and modern instances;"
which (_horrendum dictu!_) has been explained, and, I verily believe,
is generally understood to mean, _full of wise sayings and modern
illustrations_. The true meaning is--full of proverbial maxims of
conduct and of trivial arguments; that is, of petty distinctions,
or verbal disputes, such as never touch the point at issue. The word
_modern_ I have already deduced; the word _instances_ is equally Latin,
and equally used by Shakspeare in its Latin sense. It is originally
the word _instantia_, which, by the monkish and scholastic writers,
is uniformly used in the sense of an argument, and originally of an
argument urged in objection to some previous argument. [Footnote: I
cannot for a moment believe that the original and most eloquent critic
in _Blackwood_ is himself the dupe of an argument, which he has alleged
against this passage, under too open a hatred of Shakspeare, as though
it involved a contradiction to common sense, by representing _all_
human beings of such an age as school-boys, all of such another age as
soldiers, of such another as magistrates, &c. Evidently the logic of
the famous passage is this that whereas every age has its peculiar and
appropriate temper, that profession or employment is selected for the
exemplification which seems best fitted, in each case, to embody the
characteristic or predominating quality. Thus, because impetuosity,
self-esteem, and animal or irreflective courage, are qualities most
intense in youth, next it is considered in what profession those
qualities find their most unlimited range; and because that is obviously
the military profession, therefore it is that the soldier is selected as
the representative of young men. For the same reason, as best embodying
the peculiar temper of garrulous old age, the magistrate comes forward
as supporting the part of that age. Not that old men are not also
soldiers; but that the military profession, so far from strengthening,
moderates and tempers the characteristic temper of old age.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account