Mendel's principles of heredity: A defenceMendel, Gregor
Science
Mendel's principles of heredity: A defence
Mendel, Gregor
Heredity; Hybridization; Mendel's law; Weldon, Walter Frank Raphael. Mendel's laws of alternative inheritance in peas
Before examining the quality of this rather miscellaneous ammunition I
would wish to draw the non-botanical reader’s attention to one or two
facts of a general nature.
For our present purpose the seed of a pea may be considered as
consisting of two parts, the _embryo with its cotyledons_, enclosed in
a _seed-coat_. It has been known for about a century that this coat or
skin is a _maternal_ structure, being part of the mother plant just
as much as the pods are, and consequently not belonging to the next
generation at all. If then any changes take place in it consequent
on fertilisation, they are to be regarded not as in any sense a
transmission of character by heredity, but rather as of the nature
of an “infection.” If on the other hand it is desired to study the
influence of hereditary transmission on seed-coat characters, then the
crossed seeds must be sown and the seed-coats of their seeds studied.
Such infective changes in maternal tissues have been known from early
times, a notable collection of them having been made especially by
Darwin; and for these cases Focke suggested the convenient word
_Xenia_. With this familiar fact I would not for a moment suppose
Professor Weldon unacquainted, though it was with some surprise that I
found in his paper no reference to the phenomenon.
For as it happens, xenia is not at all a rare occurrence with _certain
varieties_ of peas; though in them, as I believe is generally the case
with this phenomenon, it is highly irregular in its manifestations,
being doubtless dependent on slight differences of conditions during
ripening.
The coats of peas differ greatly in different varieties, being
sometimes thick and white or yellow, sometimes thick and highly
pigmented with green or other colours, in both of which cases it
may be impossible to judge the cotyledon-colour without peeling
off the opaque coat; or the coats may be very thin, colourless and
transparent, so that the cotyledon-colour is seen at once. It was
such a transparent form that Mendel says he used for his experiments
with cotyledon-colour. In order to see xenia a pea with a _pigmented_
seed-coat should be taken as seed-parent, and crossed with a variety
having a different cotyledon-colour. There is then a fair chance of
seeing this phenomenon, but much still depends on the variety. For
example, _Fillbasket_ has green cotyledons and seed-coat green except
near the hilar surface. Crossed with _Serpette nain blanc_ (yellow
cotyledons and yellow coat) this variety gave three pods with 17 seeds
in which the seed-coats were almost full yellow (xenia). Three other
pods (25 seeds), similarly produced, showed slight xenia, and one pod
with eight seeds showed little or none.
On the other hand _Fillbasket_ fertilised with _nain de Bretagne_
(yellow cotyledons, seed-coats yellow to yellowish green) gave six pods
with 39 seeds showing slight xenia, distinct in a few seeds but absent
in most.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account