Mental diseases: a public health problemMay, James Vance
Science
Mental diseases: a public health problem
May, James Vance
Mental health services; Psychology, Pathological
One of the first advances which contributed materially to the
ultimate solution of the general paresis problem was the study of the
cerebrospinal fluid by Widal, Sicard and others after the introduction
of lumbar puncture by Quincke in 1890. This led eventually to
discoveries which were of great diagnostic importance. The isolation
of the spirochaeta pallidum, now known as the treponema pallidum, by
Schaudinn in 1905 settled the question for all time as to the cause
of syphilis. The adaptation of the principle of complement fixation,
the so-called Bordet-Gengon phenomenon, to the study of syphilitic
fluids by Wassermann, Neisser and Bruck in 1906 practically removed all
doubt as to the relation between that disease and general paresis. The
demonstration of the treponema in the cortex of paretics by Moore and
Noguchi in 1913 was practically the only other contribution necessary.
They have since been found in the cerebrospinal fluid. Notwithstanding
the fact that general paresis must now be looked upon as being a
manifestation of syphilis beyond all peradventure of a doubt, it is
nevertheless true that we are unable to explain why that disease does
not always yield to specific treatment. This is undeniably the case at
this time. Just why this should be so cannot be explained in the light
of our present knowledge. It is, however, presumably for the same reason
that tabes and other diseases of the cord and nervous system,
the specific origin of which cannot logically be questioned, are
equally resistant to salvarsan and mercury, whatever that reason may be.
As soon as the findings of the Wassermann reaction became evident,
renewed efforts on the part of clinicians to find a cure for general
paresis naturally followed. One of the first suggested was the
Swift-Ellis treatment. This was based on the injection of salvarsanized
blood serum into the subdural space of the spinal canal. Results were
exceedingly encouraging for a while, but time showed that this was
not the solution of the problem. Intravenous salvarsan administration
was next tried. This, too, gave excellent results at first. The cases
which were apparently cured, however, eventually relapsed sooner or
later in almost every instance. The intraspinous use of salvarsan in
minute doses has been no more successful than the Swift-Ellis method.
Intracranial subdural treatments have been tried and salvarsan has
even been injected directly into the lateral ventricles. The logical
conclusion is either that the destruction of the nervous tissue has
already reached a stage which is beyond repair or that the treatment
does not reach the site of the disease.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account