Mental diseases: a public health problemMay, James Vance
Science
Mental diseases: a public health problem
May, James Vance
Mental health services; Psychology, Pathological
"Mistakes of diagnosis are most apt to be made in those cases having
in the early stages pronounced psychotic symptoms and relatively
slight defect symptoms, or in cases with few definite physical signs.
Lumbar puncture should always be made if there is any doubt about
the diagnosis. A Wassermann examination of the blood alone is not
sufficient as this does not tell us whether or not the central nervous
system is involved."
A study of the statistics of the thirteen New York state hospitals
in the "pre-Wassermann" days and before we had acquired our present
accurate knowledge of the pathology of general paresis shows that there
were 84,152 admissions during the fourteen years ending on October
1, 1888. Of this number 5,697, or 6.76 per cent, were diagnosed as
general paresis. In the same hospitals, from 1912 to 1919 inclusive,
6,374 cases of general paresis were reported,—12.71 per cent of
the 49,640 first admissions. During the years 1918 and 1919 that
disease constituted 13.19 per cent of all admissions. This apparent
increase undoubtedly is due to the fact that modern methods have
materially improved facilities for accuracy of diagnosis. It is not
at all probable that the admission rate has doubled during the period
in question for any other reason. In the Massachusetts hospitals
during the year 1919, only 7.90 per cent of the first admissions were
diagnosed as general paresis. There was, however, an unusually high
rate of cerebral syphilis. In twenty-one hospitals in fourteen other
states, reports based on the present classification show a total of
18,336 admissions, mostly in 1917, 1918 and 1919. Of this number 1,233,
or 6.72 per cent, were cases of general paresis. Thus, in a total of
70,987 admissions based on the present classification of psychoses as
used by the American Psychiatric Association there were 7,845 cases
of general paresis in all,—a percentage of 11.05. It is, of course,
a well-known fact that general paresis is largely a psychosis of
densely populated communities. This is readily shown by the New York
statistics. During the year 1919, 9.6 per cent of the admissions at
Binghamton were cases of general paresis. The percentage at Buffalo
was 15.5; at Gowanda, 17.3; Hudson River (Poughkeepsie), 9.0; at
Middletown, 3.7; Rochester, 8.6; St. Lawrence (Ogdensburg), 9.2;
Utica, 10.1; and Willard, 13. In the institutions caring for the insane
of New York City 16.3 per cent were reported at the Manhattan State
Hospital, 13.5 per cent at Kings Park, and 14.7 per cent at Central
Islip. The percentage at the other institutions, except at Buffalo
and Gowanda, which care almost entirely for residents of the city of
Buffalo, is determined very largely by the transfer of patients from
the hospitals of New York City and the metropolitan district. General
paresis constitutes approximately ten per cent of the commitments in
the city of Boston. On the other hand, we find an admission rate of
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account