In the introduction to the book written by Dreyfus in 1907, Kraepelin nevertheless expressed the opinion that "These results show that for the most of these disorders which have been designated as melancholia there now exists no sufficient reason to separate them from manic-depressive insanity." This at the time was looked upon as definitely settling the fate of the melancholia concept and it was abandoned by some. As a general rule, however, the psychiatrists of this country seem to have accepted Kraepelin's original description of the disease as being thoroughly justified. To use White's words, "Many psychiatrists still believe, although Kraepelin himself accepts Dreyfus' conclusions, that there is still a place for involution melancholia distinct from the manic-depressive group." In his eighth edition Kraepelin[286] discusses melancholia as a presenile condition and reviews the whole situation in considerable detail. He shows that symptomatic considerations alone did not guide him in his original conception of the disease. A great deal of weight was attached to prognosis and certain forms were separated out and differentiated from manic-depressive because they tended towards mental enfeeblement. He calls attention to the fact that Thalbitzer disputed the integrity of melancholia in 1905, classifying it as a manic-depressive reaction. After reviewing the findings of Dreyfus he admits that the conclusions of the latter are in the main correct and that involution melancholia as originally described cannot be retained as a definite entity. "The significant fact still remains," he says, "that single attacks of depression are disproportionately common in the involution period." Hübner, for instance, found twenty-one single attacks of melancholia after the fiftieth year of age to only two single attacks of mania. "The appearance of depressions, therefore, through the revolutions of this period of life seems to be favored to a special degree." He again states that he is unable to determine what rôle is played in the involutional depressions by beginning arteriosclerosis or the onset of senile conditions. He concludes, however, that a form of depression, earlier described as melancholia, is still to be separated from the manic-depressive psychoses although not entirely clear as to its significance or exact delimitation.[287]