Christian socialism -- Fiction; German Americans -- Fiction; Shoemakers -- Fiction
“Does military discipline, when it is strict and thoroughgoing, ever
produce a dead level of commonplace?” asked Mr. Clare. “It is true that
the soldier on duty must be a mere machine; but he is an intelligent,
self-acting machine. He obeys, but it is not blind obedience; for he
knows at least the general aim, though not, perhaps, the particular
object sought to be gained, and has his own opinion as to the means
employed. At Balaklava, you remember,—
“‘the soldier knew
Some one had blundered.’
Indeed, I do not believe military discipline is at all possible, except
with highly developed individualities, which is one reason that a
Communal form of government has never been possible until now. Then,
too, the constant effort of the soldier is to distinguish himself by
rising above the common level.”
“To distinguish _himself_, to surpass _others_! Are they good motives,
Clare?”
“To surpass others in diligence and devotion to the common weal?” said
Mr. Clare. “It is a motive that is never found unmixed, rector, either
with love of one’s self or love of one’s fellows; in the last case I
should not call it a bad motive.”
“But in the first?” said the rector.
“Well, ambition in a good cause is better than ambition in a bad one, of
which we have so much nowadays. I should call it a motive which would be
likely to purify itself as it went along, or else come to signal grief,
as in the case of Judas.”
“Ah! you take _that_ view of Judas’s character!” cried the rector,
whereupon the discussion glided into another channel.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account